Ellaway Rachel H, Bates Joanna, Teunissen Pim W
Department of Community Health Sciences, Cumming School of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Faculty of Medicine, Department of Family Practice, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Med Educ. 2017 Dec;51(12):1250-1259. doi: 10.1111/medu.13406. Epub 2017 Aug 30.
Contemporary medical practice is subject to many kinds of change, to which both individuals and systems have to respond and adapt. Many medical education programmes have their learners rotating through different training contexts, which means that they too must learn to adapt to contextual change. Contextual change presents many challenges to medical education scholars and practitioners, not least because of a somewhat fractured and contested theoretical basis for responding to these challenges. There is a need for robust concepts to articulate and connect the various debates on contextual change in medical education. Ecological theories of systems encompass a range of concepts of how and why systems change and how and why they respond to change. The use of these concepts has the potential to help medical education scholars explore the nature of change and understand the role it plays in affording as well as limiting teaching and learning.
This paper, aimed at health professional education scholars and policy makers, explores a number of key concepts from ecological theories of systems to present a comprehensive model of contextual change in medical education to inform theory and practice in all areas of medical education.
The paper considers a range of concepts drawn from ecological theories of systems, including biotic and abiotic factors, panarchy, attractors and repellers, basins of attraction, homeostasis, resilience, adaptability, transformability and hysteresis. Each concept is grounded in practical examples from medical education.
Ecological theories of systems consider change and response in terms of adaptive cycles functioning at different scales and speeds. This can afford opportunities for systematic consideration of responses to contextual change in medical education, which in turn can inform the design of education programmes, activities, evaluations, assessments and research that accommodates the dynamics and consequences of contextual change.
当代医疗实践面临多种变革,个人和系统都必须对此做出回应并加以适应。许多医学教育项目让学习者在不同的培训环境中轮转,这意味着他们也必须学会适应环境变化。环境变化给医学教育学者和从业者带来了诸多挑战,尤其是因为应对这些挑战的理论基础有些零散且存在争议。需要有强有力的概念来阐明并联系医学教育中关于环境变化的各种辩论。系统生态理论包含一系列关于系统如何以及为何发生变化,以及如何以及为何对变化做出反应的概念。运用这些概念有可能帮助医学教育学者探索变化的本质,并理解其在促进以及限制教学和学习方面所起的作用。
本文面向卫生专业教育学者和政策制定者,探讨系统生态理论中的一些关键概念,以呈现医学教育环境变化的综合模型,为医学教育各领域的理论和实践提供参考。
本文考量了一系列源自系统生态理论的概念,包括生物和非生物因素、泛archy、吸引子和排斥子、吸引域、稳态、恢复力、适应性、可转化性和滞后现象。每个概念都基于医学教育的实际例子。
系统生态理论从在不同规模和速度上运作的适应性循环的角度来考量变化和反应。这为系统思考医学教育中对环境变化的应对提供了机会,进而可为适应环境变化的动态性和后果的教育项目、活动、评估、评价和研究的设计提供参考。