Kim Sug Won, Park Beom, Lee Tae Geun, Kim Ji Ye
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Wonju College of Medicine, Yonsei University, Wonju, Korea.
Arch Craniofac Surg. 2017 Jun;18(2):92-96. doi: 10.7181/acfs.2017.18.2.92. Epub 2017 Jun 26.
All nasal bone fractures have the potential for worsening of olfactory function. However, few studies have studied the olfactory outcomes following reduction of nasal bone fractures. This study evaluates posttraumatic olfactory dysfunction in patients with nasal bone fracture before and after closed reduction.
A prospective study was conducted for all patients presenting with nasal bone fracture (n=97). Each patient consenting to the study underwent the Korean version of Sniffin' Sticks test (KVSS II) before operation and at 6 month after closed reduction. The nasal fractures were divided according to the nasal bone fracture classification by Haug and Prather (Types I-IV). The olfactory scores were compared across fracture types and between preoperative and postoperative settings.
Olfactory dysfunction was frequent after nasal fracture (45/97, 46.4%). Our olfactory assessment using the KVSS II test revealed that fracture reduction was not associated with improvements in the mean test score in Type I or Type II fractures. More specifically, the mean posttraumatic Threshold, discrimination and identification score decreased from 28.8 points prior to operation to 23.1 point at 6 months for Type II fracture with septal fracture.
Our study has revealed two alarming trends regarding post-nasal fracture olfactory dysfunction. First, our study demonstrated that almost half (46.4%) of nasal fracture patients experience posttraumatic olfactory dysfunction. Second, closed reduction of these fractures does not lead to improvements olfaction at 6 months, which suggest that olfactory dysfunction is probably due to factors other than the fracture itself. The association should be further explored between injuries that lead to nasal fracture and the mechanism behind posttraumatic olfactory dysfunction.
所有鼻骨骨折都有可能导致嗅觉功能恶化。然而,很少有研究探讨鼻骨骨折复位后的嗅觉转归。本研究评估鼻骨骨折患者在闭合复位前后的创伤后嗅觉功能障碍。
对所有鼻骨骨折患者(n = 97)进行前瞻性研究。每位同意参与研究的患者在手术前及闭合复位后6个月接受韩国版嗅觉棒测试(KVSS II)。鼻骨骨折根据Haug和Prather的鼻骨骨折分类法(I-IV型)进行划分。比较不同骨折类型以及术前和术后的嗅觉评分。
鼻骨骨折后嗅觉功能障碍很常见(45/97,46.4%)。我们使用KVSS II测试进行的嗅觉评估显示,I型或II型骨折复位后平均测试评分并未改善。更具体地说,伴有鼻中隔骨折的II型骨折患者,创伤后平均阈值、辨别力和识别评分从术前的28.8分降至6个月时的23.1分。
我们的研究揭示了关于鼻骨骨折后嗅觉功能障碍的两个惊人趋势。首先,我们的研究表明,几乎一半(46.4%)的鼻骨骨折患者存在创伤后嗅觉功能障碍。其次,这些骨折的闭合复位在6个月时并未改善嗅觉,这表明嗅觉功能障碍可能是由骨折本身以外的因素导致的。导致鼻骨骨折的损伤与创伤后嗅觉功能障碍背后的机制之间的关联应进一步探讨。