VA HSR&D Center for Chronic Disease Outcomes Research, Minneapolis VA Healthcare System, 1 Veterans Drive (152), Minneapolis, MN, 55417, USA.
Department of Medicine, University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2017 Dec;32(12):1359-1376. doi: 10.1007/s11606-017-4152-5. Epub 2017 Sep 14.
Women comprise a growing proportion of Veterans seeking care at Veterans Affairs (VA) healthcare facilities. VA initiatives have accelerated changes in services for female Veterans, yet the corresponding literature has not been systematically reviewed since 2008. In 2015, VA Women's Health Services and the VA Women's Health Research Network requested an updated literature review to facilitate policy and research planning.
The Minneapolis VA Evidence-based Synthesis Program performed a systematic search of research related to female Veterans' health published from 2008 through 2015. We extracted study characteristics including healthcare topic, design, sample size and proportion female, research setting, and funding source. We created an evidence map by organizing and presenting results within and across healthcare topics, and describing patterns, strengths, and gaps.
We identified 2276 abstracts and assessed each for relevance. We excluded 1092 abstracts and reviewed 1184 full-text articles; 750 were excluded. Of 440 included articles, 208 (47%) were related to mental health, particularly post-traumatic stress disorder (71 articles), military sexual trauma (37 articles), and substance abuse (20 articles). The number of articles addressing VA priority topic areas increased over time, including reproductive health, healthcare organization and delivery, access and utilization, and post-deployment health. Three or fewer articles addressed each of the common chronic diseases: diabetes, hypertension, depression, or anxiety. Nearly 400 articles (90%) used an observational design. Eight articles (2%) described randomized trials.
Our evidence map summarizes patterns, progress, and growth in the female Veterans' health and healthcare literature. Observational studies in mental health make up the majority of research. A focus on primary care delivery over clinical topics in primary care and a lack of sex-specific results for studies that include men and women have contributed to research gaps in addressing common chronic diseases. Interventional research using randomized trials is needed.
在寻求退伍军人事务部 (VA) 医疗保健服务的退伍军人中,女性所占比例不断增加。VA 采取的各种举措加快了女性退伍军人服务的变革,但自 2008 年以来,相关文献尚未进行系统审查。2015 年,VA 妇女健康服务和 VA 妇女健康研究网络要求进行更新的文献综述,以促进政策和研究规划。
明尼阿波利斯退伍军人事务部循证综合计划对 2008 年至 2015 年期间发表的与女性退伍军人健康相关的研究进行了系统搜索。我们提取了研究特征,包括医疗保健主题、设计、样本量和女性比例、研究环境和资金来源。我们通过在医疗保健主题内和主题之间组织和呈现结果,描述模式、优势和差距,创建了一个证据图。
我们确定了 2276 篇摘要,并对每一篇摘要进行了相关性评估。我们排除了 1092 篇摘要,审查了 1184 篇全文文章;排除了 750 篇。在 440 篇纳入的文章中,208 篇(47%)与心理健康有关,特别是创伤后应激障碍(71 篇)、军事性创伤(37 篇)和物质滥用(20 篇)。随着时间的推移,解决 VA 优先主题领域的文章数量有所增加,包括生殖健康、医疗保健组织和提供、获得和利用以及部署后健康。每篇文章都涉及到三种或三种以下常见慢性疾病:糖尿病、高血压、抑郁或焦虑。近 400 篇文章(90%)采用观察性设计。8 篇文章(2%)描述了随机试验。
我们的证据图总结了女性退伍军人健康和医疗保健文献的模式、进展和增长。在心理健康方面的观察性研究构成了大多数研究。在初级保健中,重点关注初级保健的医疗服务提供,而不是临床主题,以及在包括男性和女性的研究中缺乏性别特异性结果,这导致了常见慢性疾病研究的空白。需要进行使用随机试验的干预性研究。