Faculty of Biochemistry, Biophysics and Biotechnology, Jagiellonian University in Kraków, Gronostajowa 7, 30-387, Kraków, Poland.
Sci Rep. 2017 Sep 15;7(1):11682. doi: 10.1038/s41598-017-11067-6.
SmartFlare probes have recently emerged as a promising tool for visualisation and quantification of specific RNAs in living cells. They are supposed to overcome the common drawbacks of current methods for RNA analysis: the need of cell fixation or lysis, or the requirements for genetic manipulations. In contrast to the traditional methods, SmartFlare probes are also presumed to provide information on RNA levels in single cells. Disappointingly, the results of our comprehensive study involving probes specific to five different transcripts, HMOX1, IL6, PTGS2, Nrg1, and ERBB4, deny the usefulness of SmartFlare probes for RNA analysis. We report a total lack of correlation between fluorescence intensities of SmartFlare probes and the levels of corresponding RNAs assessed by RT-qPCR. To ensure strong differences in the levels of analysed RNAs, their expression was modified via: (i) HMOX1-knockdown generated by CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing, (ii) hemin-mediated stimulation of HMOX1- and IL1β-mediated stimulation of IL6- and PTGS2 transcription, (iii) lentiviral vector-mediated Nrg1 overexpression. Additionally, ERBB4-specific SmartFlare probe failed to distinguish between ERBB4-expressing and non-expressing cell lines. Finally, we demonstrated that fluorescence intensity of HMOX1-specific SmartFlare probe corresponds to the efficacy of its uptake and/or accumulation.
SmartFlare 探针最近作为一种有前途的工具出现,用于可视化和量化活细胞中特定的 RNA。它们应该克服当前 RNA 分析方法的常见缺点:需要细胞固定或裂解,或需要遗传操作。与传统方法相比,SmartFlare 探针还被认为可以提供单细胞中 RNA 水平的信息。令人失望的是,我们对涉及 5 种不同转录物(HMOX1、IL6、PTGS2、Nrg1 和 ERBB4)特异性探针的综合研究的结果否定了 SmartFlare 探针在 RNA 分析中的有用性。我们报告说,SmartFlare 探针的荧光强度与通过 RT-qPCR 评估的相应 RNA 水平之间完全没有相关性。为了确保分析的 RNA 水平有很大差异,通过以下方式修饰其表达:(i) 通过 CRISPR-Cas9 基因组编辑产生的 HMOX1 敲低,(ii) 血红素介导的 HMOX1 刺激,IL1β 介导的 IL6 和 PTGS2 转录刺激,(iii) 慢病毒载体介导的 Nrg1 过表达。此外,特异性 SmartFlare 探针不能区分 ERBB4 表达和非表达细胞系。最后,我们证明了 HMOX1 特异性 SmartFlare 探针的荧光强度与它的摄取和/或积累的效果相对应。