Gottlieb Jens
Department of Respiratory Medicine, Hannover Medical School, Hannover, Germany.
Biomedical Research in End-stage and Obstructive Disease (BREATH), German Centre for Lung Research (DZL), Hannover, Germany.
J Thorac Dis. 2017 Aug;9(8):2670-2674. doi: 10.21037/jtd.2017.07.83.
Shortage of donor lungs in most western countries and broadening of indications for lung transplantation (LTx) has led increased waiting list mortality in the past. Usually donor lungs and recipients are matched by size as measured by total lung capacity and blood type in first order. In some countries regional allocation comes first, in other countries a national wait list exists and some nations are organized in supranational allocation systems. Organ distribution should respect the ethical principles of equity, justice, beneficence and utility. Generally, top priority on the list should be given to patients with the least amount of time to live but outcome is an important factor to consider to avoid futile transplantations. Installation of an urgency status will decrease mortality of the sickest candidates on the waitlist unless the proportion of patients on urgency status will be too high. Urgency can be determined by clinical judgment (so called center decision), an audit process or objectively by a score system. Among the 3,500 transplants performed worldwide annually, approximately 60% are allocated by lung allocation score (LAS) (US, Germany, the Netherlands). With the LAS a model for survival prediction after lung transplantation and wait list survival probability was created. Clinical experience in the US since 2005 and in Germany since 2011 favourable reports regarding effects on waiting list outflow, transplant activity and outcomes have been published. Future perspectives will focus on broader geographic sharing, updating and further development of the LAS.
在大多数西方国家,供体肺短缺以及肺移植(LTx)适应症的扩大导致过去等待名单上的死亡率上升。通常,供体肺和受体首先根据总肺容量和血型所衡量的大小进行匹配。在一些国家,区域分配优先;在其他国家,存在全国性的等待名单,还有一些国家组织了超国家分配系统。器官分配应遵循公平、公正、有益和效用的伦理原则。一般来说,名单上的最高优先级应给予存活时间最短的患者,但结果是避免徒劳移植需要考虑的一个重要因素。设立紧急状态将降低等待名单上病情最严重的候选者的死亡率,除非处于紧急状态的患者比例过高。紧急状态可以通过临床判断(所谓的中心决定)、审核过程或客观地通过评分系统来确定。在全球每年进行的3500例移植手术中,约60%是通过肺分配评分(LAS)(美国、德国、荷兰)进行分配的。借助LAS创建了一个肺移植后生存预测和等待名单生存概率的模型。自2005年以来美国以及自2011年以来德国的临床经验表明,已发表了关于对等待名单流出、移植活动和结果影响的有利报告。未来的展望将集中在更广泛的地理共享、LAS的更新和进一步发展上。