Slimani Maamer, Davis Philip, Franchini Emerson, Moalla Wassim
1Research Laboratory "Sport Performance Optimization", National Center of Medicine and Science in Sport (CNMSS), El Menzah, Tunisia;2Combat Sports Performance, Braintree, Essex, United Kingdom;3Martial Arts and Combat Sports Research Group, School of Physical Education and Sport, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil; and4UR15JS01 EM2S: Education, Motricity, Sport and Health, High Institute of Sport and Physical Education, University of Sfax, Sfax, Tunisia.
J Strength Cond Res. 2017 Oct;31(10):2889-2902. doi: 10.1519/JSC.0000000000002047.
The aim of this short review was to summarize data pertaining to the rating of perceived exertion (RPE) methods (RPE value and session-RPE) during combat sport-specific activities (i.e., competition and training) based on many factors, including contest type (i.e., official vs. simulated vs. training), combat rounds, age of participants and muscle groups, and their correlation with physiological variables (i.e., blood lactate concentration [La] and heart rate [HR]). The current review shows higher RPE in a match of mixed martial arts (MMAs) than Brazilian jiu-jitsu and kickboxing matches and during the competitive period compared with the precompetitive period. This could be explained by the longer duration of bouts, the higher percentage contribution of aerobic metabolism in MMA than other combat sports and contest type differences (simulated vs. official matches). Thus, this review found significant correlations between RPE or session-RPE, [La] and HR. Particularly, there was a stronger correlation between RPE and [La] during official striking (r = 0.81) than grappling combat sports matches (r = 0.53). In addition, a variation of correlation (moderate to large) between session-RPE and HR-based methods has been reported (i.e., Edwards' training load [r ranged between 0.58 and 0.95] and Banister training impulse [r ranged between 0.52 and 0.86]). Specifically, stronger correlation was apparent in combat sport competition that required a much higher percentage contribution of aerobic metabolism (e.g., karate) and in adult athletes than anaerobic-based combat sports (e.g., taekwondo) and young athletes, respectively. Indeed, the current review highlights that the correlations between session-RPE and HR-based methods were higher during official competition than training sessions. Session-RPE was affected by participants' competitive level, the intensity of session (high vs. low), the training modalities (tactical-technical vs. technical-development vs. simulated competition), and the training volume in combat sports athletes. Rating of perceived exertion is a valid tool for quantifying internal training and combat loads during short- and long-term training and simulated and official competitions in novice and elite combat sport athletes. Furthermore, both RPE methods may be a more reliable measure of intensity or effort when both anaerobic and aerobic systems are appreciably activated. Coaches, sports scientists, and athletes can use session-RPE method to quantify short-term training and combat loads in adult athletes during precompetitive period much more than long-term training and in young athletes during the competitive period. They can also use RPE to monitor combat and short- and long-term training loads to better plan and assist training programs and competitions.
本简短综述的目的是基于多种因素,包括比赛类型(即官方比赛、模拟比赛与训练)、战斗回合数、参与者年龄和肌肉群,总结格斗运动特定活动(即比赛和训练)中与主观用力程度(RPE)方法(RPE值和训练RPE)相关的数据,以及它们与生理变量(即血乳酸浓度[La]和心率[HR])的相关性。当前综述表明,综合格斗(MMA)比赛中的RPE高于巴西柔术和踢拳比赛,且与赛前阶段相比,比赛期间的RPE更高。这可以通过比赛持续时间更长、MMA中 aerobic metabolism 的贡献百分比高于其他格斗运动以及比赛类型差异(模拟比赛与官方比赛)来解释。因此,本综述发现RPE或训练RPE与[La]和HR之间存在显著相关性。特别是,在官方打击比赛中(r = 0.81),RPE与[La]之间的相关性比格斗类竞技运动比赛(r = 0.53)更强。此外,已有报道称训练RPE与基于心率的方法之间存在不同程度的相关性(中等至较大)(即爱德华兹训练负荷[r在0.58至0.95之间]和巴尼斯特训练冲量[r在0.52至0.86之间])。具体而言,在需要更高百分比 aerobic metabolism 贡献的格斗运动比赛(如空手道)中以及成年运动员中,相关性比基于无氧代谢的格斗运动(如跆拳道)和年轻运动员中更明显。事实上,当前综述强调,在官方比赛期间,训练RPE与基于心率的方法之间的相关性高于训练阶段。训练RPE受参与者的竞技水平、训练强度(高与低)、训练方式(战术技术训练、技术发展训练与模拟比赛)以及格斗运动运动员的训练量影响。主观用力程度评级是量化新手和精英格斗运动运动员短期和长期训练以及模拟和官方比赛中的内部训练和战斗负荷的有效工具。此外,当无氧和有氧系统均被显著激活时,两种RPE方法可能是强度或努力程度的更可靠衡量指标。教练、运动科学家和运动员可以使用训练RPE方法来量化成年运动员在赛前阶段的短期训练和战斗负荷,而在长期训练中以及年轻运动员在比赛期间则使用得更多。他们还可以使用RPE来监测战斗以及短期和长期训练负荷,以便更好地规划和协助训练计划及比赛。