Olabarrieta-Landa Laiene, Torre Esther Landa, López-Mugartza Juan Carlos, Bialystok Ellen, Arango-Lasprilla Juan Carlos
Department of Education and Psychology, University of Deusto, Bilbao, Spain.
Department of Philology and Didactics of the Language, Public University of Navarre, Pamplona, Spain.
NeuroRehabilitation. 2017;41(2):539-565. doi: 10.3233/NRE-162102.
To conduct a literature review of the administration and scoring criteria used in normative studies of verbal fluency tests (VFT), and to propose a new model for the administration and scoring of phonological, semantic, and action VFT for use in Spanish-speakers.
A literature search was performed using four databases Dialnet, ProQuest (PsycINFO, PsycArticles), Science Direct (Elsevier), and PubMed and 47 articles met the following criteria: 1) articles which contained normative data of phonological, semantic, or action VFT, 2) published between 2000 and 2015, 3) published in English or Spanish, 4) used healthy population.
Of 2087 citations retrieved, 47 eligible studies were reviewed. The majority of the studies have been conducted in the USA, and with English and Spanish speakers. Only 12 studies provided the instruction, and 23 clearly describe the scoring guidelines. Moreover, among the studies that provided these information important discrepancies were found. Therefore, a new administration and scoring guidelines are presented, which may resolve this problem and be utilized in Spanish speaking countries.
This review showed that still there is no consensus regarding the administration and scoring of VFT. A new method of administration and scoring is presented that can be use with Spanish-speakers.
对言语流畅性测试(VFT)规范研究中使用的施测方法和评分标准进行文献综述,并提出一种适用于西班牙语使用者的语音、语义和动作VFT施测及评分新模型。
使用Dialnet、ProQuest(PsycINFO、PsycArticles)、Science Direct(爱思唯尔)和PubMed四个数据库进行文献检索,47篇文章符合以下标准:1)包含语音、语义或动作VFT规范数据的文章;2)2000年至2015年发表;3)以英文或西班牙文发表;4)使用健康人群。
在检索到的2087条引用中,对47项符合条件的研究进行了综述。大多数研究在美国进行,涉及英语和西班牙语使用者。只有12项研究提供了指导说明,23项明确描述了评分指南。此外,在提供这些信息的研究中发现了重要差异。因此,提出了一种新的施测和评分指南,可解决这一问题并在西班牙语国家使用。
本综述表明,关于VFT的施测和评分仍未达成共识。提出了一种新的施测和评分方法,可用于西班牙语使用者。