Qin Yun, Xin Xiuwei, Zhu Hao, Li Fali, Xiong Hongchuan, Zhang Tao, Lai Yongxiu
Key Laboratory for NeuroInformation of Ministry of Education, Center for Information in Medicine, University of Electronic Science and Technology of ChinaChengdu, China.
High-Field Magnetic Resonance Brain Imaging Key Laboratory of Sichuan Province, School of Life Science and Technology, University of Electronic Science and Technology of ChinaChengdu, China.
Front Neurosci. 2017 Sep 12;11:509. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2017.00509. eCollection 2017.
One of the most fundamental issues during an EEG study is choosing an available neutral reference. The infinity zero reference obtained by the reference electrode standardization technique (REST) has been recommended and used for its higher accuracy. This paper examined three traditional references, the average reference (AR), the linked mastoids reference (LM), and REST, in the study of the EEG center of mass (CM) using simulated and real ERPs. In the simulation, the relative error of REST was the smallest among the references. As for the ERP data with the visual oddball paradigm, the dynamic CM trajectory and its traveling velocity obtained by REST characterized three typical stages in spatial domain and temporal speed metrics, which provided useful information in addition to the distinct ERP waveform in the temporal domain. The results showed that the CM traveling from the frontal to parietal areas corresponding to the earlier positive components (i.e., P200 and P250), stays temporarily at the parietal area corresponding to P300 and then returns to the frontal area during the recovery stage. Compared with REST, AR, and LM not only changed the amplitude of P300 significantly but distorted the CM trajectory and its instantaneous velocity. As REST continues to provide objective results, we recommend that REST be used in future EEG/ERP CM studies.
脑电图(EEG)研究中最基本的问题之一是选择一个可用的中性参考。参考电极标准化技术(REST)获得的无穷大零参考因其更高的准确性而被推荐和使用。本文在使用模拟和真实事件相关电位(ERP)研究EEG质心(CM)时,考察了三种传统参考,即平均参考(AR)、联合乳突参考(LM)和REST。在模拟中,REST的相对误差在各参考中最小。对于视觉oddball范式的ERP数据,REST获得的动态CM轨迹及其移动速度在空间域和时间速度指标上表征了三个典型阶段,除了时域中明显的ERP波形外,还提供了有用信息。结果表明,CM从对应早期正成分(即P200和P250)的额叶向顶叶区域移动,在对应P300的顶叶区域暂时停留,然后在恢复阶段返回额叶区域。与REST相比,AR和LM不仅显著改变了P300的幅度,还扭曲了CM轨迹及其瞬时速度。由于REST持续提供客观结果,我们建议在未来的EEG/ERP CM研究中使用REST。