Ogden Nicholas H
Public Health Risk Science Division, National Microbiology Laboratory, Public Health Agency of Canada, 3200 Sicotte, Saint-Hyacinthe, QC J2S 2M2, Canada.
FEMS Microbiol Lett. 2017 Oct 16;364(19). doi: 10.1093/femsle/fnx186.
There has been much debate as to whether or not climate change will have, or has had, any significant effect on risk from vector-borne diseases. The debate on the former has focused on the degree to which occurrence and levels of risk of vector-borne diseases are determined by climate-dependent or independent factors, while the debate on the latter has focused on whether changes in disease incidence are due to climate at all, and/or are attributable to recent climate change. Here I review possible effects of climate change on vector-borne diseases, methods used to predict these effects and the evidence to date of changes in vector-borne disease risks that can be attributed to recent climate change. Predictions have both over- and underestimated the effects of climate change. Mostly under-estimations of effects are due to a focus only on direct effects of climate on disease ecology while more distal effects on society's capacity to control and prevent vector-borne disease are ignored. There is increasing evidence for possible impacts of recent climate change on some vector-borne diseases but for the most part, observed data series are too short (or non-existent), and impacts of climate-independent factors too great, to confidently attribute changing risk to climate change.
关于气候变化是否会对媒介传播疾病的风险产生重大影响,或者是否已经产生了重大影响,一直存在很多争论。关于前者的争论集中在媒介传播疾病的发生和风险水平在多大程度上由气候相关或气候无关因素决定,而关于后者的争论则集中在疾病发病率的变化是否完全归因于气候,以及/或者是否可归因于近期的气候变化。在此,我回顾了气候变化对媒介传播疾病可能产生的影响、用于预测这些影响的方法以及迄今为止可归因于近期气候变化的媒介传播疾病风险变化的证据。预测对气候变化的影响既有高估也有低估。大多数低估是由于只关注气候对疾病生态的直接影响,而忽略了对社会控制和预防媒介传播疾病能力的更间接影响。越来越多的证据表明近期气候变化可能对某些媒介传播疾病产生影响,但在大多数情况下,观测数据序列太短(或不存在),且气候无关因素的影响太大,无法确定地将风险变化归因于气候变化。