Allen Michael Todd, Jameson Molly M, Myers Catherine E
School of Psychological Sciences, University of Northern Colorado, GreeleyCO, United States.
Department of Veterans Affairs, VA New Jersey Health Care System, East OrangeNJ, United States.
Front Psychol. 2017 Sep 15;8:1560. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01560. eCollection 2017.
Personality factors such as behavioral inhibition (BI), a temperamental tendency for avoidance in the face of unfamiliar situations, have been identified as risk factors for anxiety disorders. Personality factors are generally identified through self-report inventories. However, this tendency to avoid may affect the accuracy of these self-report inventories. Previously, a computer based task was developed in which the participant guides an on-screen "avatar" through a series of onscreen events; performance on the task could accurately predict participants' BI, measured by a standard paper and pencil questionnaire (Adult Measure of Behavioral Inhibition, or AMBI). Here, we sought to replicate this finding as well as compare performance on the avatar task to another measure related to BI, the harm avoidance (HA) scale of the Tridimensional Personality Questionnaire (TPQ). The TPQ includes HA scales as well as scales assessing reward dependence (RD), novelty seeking (NS) and persistence. One hundred and one undergraduates voluntarily completed the avatar task and the paper and pencil inventories in a counter-balanced order. Scores on the avatar task were strongly correlated with BI assessed via the AMBI questionnaire, which replicates prior findings. Females exhibited higher HA scores than males, but did not differ on scores on the avatar task. There was a strong positive relationship between scores on the avatar task and HA scores. One aspect of HA, fear of uncertainty was found to moderately mediate the relationship between AMBI scores and avatar scores. NS had a strong negative relationship with scores on the avatar task, but there was no significant relationship between RD and scores on the avatar task. These findings indicate the effectiveness of the avatar task as a behavioral alternative to self-report measures to assess avoidance. In addition, the use of computer based behavioral tasks are a viable alternative to paper and pencil self-report inventories, particularly when assessing anxiety and avoidance.
人格因素,如行为抑制(BI),即面对陌生情境时的一种回避气质倾向,已被确定为焦虑症的风险因素。人格因素通常通过自我报告量表来确定。然而,这种回避倾向可能会影响这些自我报告量表的准确性。此前,开发了一项基于计算机的任务,参与者通过一系列屏幕事件来引导屏幕上的“虚拟角色”;该任务的表现能够准确预测参与者的行为抑制,通过标准纸笔问卷(成人行为抑制量表,即AMBI)来测量。在此,我们试图重复这一发现,并将虚拟角色任务的表现与另一项与行为抑制相关的测量方法进行比较,即三维人格问卷(TPQ)的伤害回避(HA)量表。TPQ包括HA量表以及评估奖赏依赖(RD)、新奇寻求(NS)和坚持性的量表。101名本科生以平衡顺序自愿完成了虚拟角色任务和纸笔问卷。虚拟角色任务的得分与通过AMBI问卷评估的行为抑制密切相关,这重复了先前的发现。女性的HA得分高于男性,但在虚拟角色任务的得分上没有差异。虚拟角色任务的得分与HA得分之间存在强烈的正相关关系。HA的一个方面,即对不确定性的恐惧,被发现适度调节了AMBI得分与虚拟角色得分之间的关系。新奇寻求与虚拟角色任务的得分有强烈的负相关关系,但奖赏依赖与虚拟角色任务的得分之间没有显著关系。这些发现表明虚拟角色任务作为一种行为方式替代自我报告测量来评估回避的有效性。此外,使用基于计算机的行为任务是纸笔自我报告量表的一种可行替代方法,特别是在评估焦虑和回避时。