Institute for Risk and Uncertainty, University of Liverpool, Chadwick Building, Peach Street, Liverpool L69 7ZF, United Kingdom; Institute of Nuclear Engineering and Science, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu, Taiwan.
Institute of Nuclear Engineering and Science, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu, Taiwan.
Neural Netw. 2017 Dec;96:80-90. doi: 10.1016/j.neunet.2017.09.003. Epub 2017 Sep 18.
Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) are commonly used in place of expensive models to reduce the computational burden required for uncertainty quantification, reliability and sensitivity analyses. ANN with selected architecture is trained with the back-propagation algorithm from few data representatives of the input/output relationship of the underlying model of interest. However, different performing ANNs might be obtained with the same training data as a result of the random initialization of the weight parameters in each of the network, leading to an uncertainty in selecting the best performing ANN. On the other hand, using cross-validation to select the best performing ANN based on the ANN with the highest R value can lead to biassing in the prediction. This is as a result of the fact that the use of R cannot determine if the prediction made by ANN is biased. Additionally, R does not indicate if a model is adequate, as it is possible to have a low R for a good model and a high R for a bad model. Hence, in this paper, we propose an approach to improve the robustness of a prediction made by ANN. The approach is based on a systematic combination of identical trained ANNs, by coupling the Bayesian framework and model averaging. Additionally, the uncertainties of the robust prediction derived from the approach are quantified in terms of confidence intervals. To demonstrate the applicability of the proposed approach, two synthetic numerical examples are presented. Finally, the proposed approach is used to perform a reliability and sensitivity analyses on a process simulation model of a UK nuclear effluent treatment plant developed by National Nuclear Laboratory (NNL) and treated in this study as a black-box employing a set of training data as a test case. This model has been extensively validated against plant and experimental data and used to support the UK effluent discharge strategy.
人工神经网络 (ANN) 常用于替代昂贵的模型,以降低不确定性量化、可靠性和敏感性分析所需的计算负担。选择架构的 ANN 使用反向传播算法从感兴趣的基础模型的输入/输出关系的少数数据代表进行训练。然而,由于每个网络中的权重参数的随机初始化,可能会得到不同表现的 ANN,从而导致在选择表现最佳的 ANN 时存在不确定性。另一方面,使用交叉验证根据 R 值最高的 ANN 选择表现最佳的 ANN 可能会导致预测存在偏差。这是因为 R 的使用不能确定 ANN 做出的预测是否存在偏差。此外,R 并不能表明模型是否充分,因为对于一个好的模型,可能会有一个低的 R 值,而对于一个坏的模型,可能会有一个高的 R 值。因此,在本文中,我们提出了一种改进 ANN 预测稳健性的方法。该方法基于相同训练的 ANN 的系统组合,通过结合贝叶斯框架和模型平均。此外,还通过置信区间来量化稳健预测的不确定性。为了演示所提出方法的适用性,本文提出了两个合成数值示例。最后,将所提出的方法用于对由国家核实验室 (NNL) 开发的英国核废水处理厂过程模拟模型进行可靠性和敏感性分析,并将其作为一个黑盒,采用一组训练数据作为测试案例进行处理。该模型已经过广泛的工厂和实验数据验证,并用于支持英国废水排放策略。