Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, CO, 80045, USA.
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Colorado Memorial Hospital, Colorado Springs, CO, 80909, USA.
Med Phys. 2017 Dec;44(12):6148-6158. doi: 10.1002/mp.12621. Epub 2017 Nov 1.
Stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) for pancreatic cancer requires a skillful approach to deliver ablative doses to the tumor while limiting dose to the highly sensitive duodenum, stomach, and small bowel. Here, we develop knowledge-based artificial neural network dose models (ANN-DMs) to predict dose distributions that would be approved by experienced physicians.
Arc-based SBRT treatment plans for 43 pancreatic cancer patients were planned, delivering 30-33 Gy in five fractions. Treatments were overseen by one of two physicians with individual treatment approaches, with variations in prescribed dose, target volume delineation, and primary organs at risk. Using dose distributions calculated by a commercial treatment planning system (TPS), physician-approved treatment plans were used to train ANN-DMs that could predict physician-approved dose distributions based on a set of geometric parameters (vary from voxel to voxel) and plan parameters (constant across all voxels for a given patient). Patient datasets were randomly allocated, with two-thirds used for training, and one-third used for validation. Differences between TPS and ANN-DM dose distributions were used to evaluate model performance. ANN-DM design, including neural network structure and parameter choices, was evaluated to optimize dose model performance.
Remarkable improvements in ANN-DM accuracy (i.e., from > 30% to < 5% mean absolute dose error, relative to the prescribed dose) were achieved by training separate dose models for the treatment style of each physician. Increased neural network complexity (i.e., more layers, more neurons per layer) did not improve dose model accuracy. Mean dose errors were less than 5% at all distances from the PTV, and mean absolute dose errors were on the order of 5%, but no more than 10%. Dose-volume histogram errors (in cm ) demonstrated good model performance above 25 Gy, but much larger errors were seen at lower doses.
ANN-DM dose distributions showed excellent overall agreement with TPS dose distributions, and accuracy was substantially improved when each physician's treatment approach was taken into account by training their own dedicated models. In this manner, one could feasibly train ANN-DMs that could predict the dose distribution desired by a given physician for a given treatment site.
立体定向体部放射治疗(SBRT)治疗胰腺癌需要一种熟练的方法,既能将消融剂量输送到肿瘤,又能限制十二指肠、胃和小肠等高度敏感器官的剂量。在这里,我们开发了基于知识的人工神经网络剂量模型(ANN-DM),以预测经验丰富的医生认可的剂量分布。
对 43 例胰腺癌患者进行基于弧的 SBRT 治疗计划,每个部位给予 30-33Gy 的 5 次分割剂量。由两位医生之一监督治疗,他们的治疗方法各不相同,包括规定剂量、靶区勾画和主要危及器官的变化。使用商业治疗计划系统(TPS)计算的剂量分布,根据一组几何参数(从体素到体素变化)和计划参数(对于给定患者的所有体素都保持不变),利用医师认可的治疗计划对 ANN-DM 进行训练,以预测医师认可的剂量分布。患者数据集随机分配,三分之二用于训练,三分之一用于验证。使用 TPS 和 ANN-DM 剂量分布之间的差异来评估模型性能。评估 ANN-DM 设计,包括神经网络结构和参数选择,以优化剂量模型性能。
通过为每位医生的治疗风格训练单独的剂量模型,显著提高了 ANN-DM 的准确性(即从超过 30%到低于 5%的平均绝对剂量误差,相对于规定剂量)。增加神经网络的复杂性(即更多的层,每层更多的神经元)并没有提高剂量模型的准确性。在 PTV 附近的所有距离处,平均剂量误差都小于 5%,平均绝对剂量误差在 5%左右,但不超过 10%。剂量-体积直方图误差(cm)在 25Gy 以上显示出良好的模型性能,但在较低剂量下误差较大。
ANN-DM 剂量分布与 TPS 剂量分布总体吻合良好,当考虑到每位医生的治疗方法,通过训练他们自己专用的模型,准确性得到了显著提高。通过这种方式,我们可以训练出 ANN-DM,它可以预测给定医生在给定治疗部位所需的剂量分布。