Dover Jeffrey S, Monheit Gary, Greener Mark, Pickett Andy
SkinCare Physicians, Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts.
Total Skin and Beauty Dermatology Center, Birmingham, Alabama.
Dermatol Surg. 2018 Feb;44(2):249-260. doi: 10.1097/DSS.0000000000001277.
Several formulations of Botulinum toxin serotype A (BoNT-A) for aesthetic indications are available, with numbers likely to increase. Preparations are not interchangeable, based on dose unit comparisons.
Numerous myths and misconceptions regarding the use of BoNT-A for aesthetic indications have arisen, which this review aims to lay to rest.
This review assesses evidence for and against each of the most common myths regarding BoNT use in aesthetics.
BoNT-A neurotoxin/protein complexes are irrelevant to the toxin's therapeutic/aesthetic indications. BoNT-A neurotoxin/protein complexes do not influence movement from injection site or immunogenicity. Any relationship between neutralizing antibody formation and clinical response is complex and clinicians should consider other factors that may induce an apparent loss of clinical response. Diffusion appears predominately, perhaps exclusively, dose dependent. Careful placement and correct dosing optimizes likelihood of good outcomes. Manufacturers recommend reconstitution of products with sterile nonpreserved saline. However, compelling evidence suggests that reconstitution using preserved saline dramatically improves patient comfort without compromising efficacy. Several post-treatment instructions/restrictions are widely used despite the lack of evidence, but muscle activity after injection may be beneficial. Cooling the treatment area might hinder BoNT-A translocation and should probably be abandoned.
The existing evidence suggests that experienced users should achieve equivalent results regardless of BoNT-A formulation, but additional, well-designed, adequately powered, controlled randomized studies should be performed.
目前有几种用于美容适应症的A型肉毒杆菌毒素(BoNT-A)制剂,且数量可能会增加。基于剂量单位比较,这些制剂不可互换。
关于将BoNT-A用于美容适应症出现了许多误解和错误观念,本综述旨在澄清这些问题。
本综述评估了支持和反对在美容中使用BoNT的最常见误解的证据。
BoNT-A神经毒素/蛋白质复合物与毒素的治疗/美容适应症无关。BoNT-A神经毒素/蛋白质复合物不会影响注射部位的运动或免疫原性。中和抗体形成与临床反应之间的任何关系都很复杂,临床医生应考虑其他可能导致临床反应明显丧失的因素。扩散似乎主要(也许完全)取决于剂量。仔细的注射部位选择和正确的剂量可优化获得良好效果的可能性。制造商建议用无菌无防腐剂的生理盐水复溶产品。然而,有力证据表明,使用含防腐剂的生理盐水复溶可显著提高患者舒适度且不影响疗效。尽管缺乏证据,但仍广泛使用几种治疗后指导/限制措施,但注射后肌肉活动可能有益。冷却治疗区域可能会阻碍BoNT-A的转运,应该摒弃。
现有证据表明,经验丰富的使用者无论使用哪种BoNT-A制剂都应能取得相同的效果,但应开展更多设计良好、有足够效力的对照随机研究。