Okami Suguru, Kohtake Naohiko
Graduate School of System Design and Management, Keio University, Kanagawa, Japan.
Front Public Health. 2017 Sep 26;5:262. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2017.00262. eCollection 2017.
Due to the associated and substantial efforts of many stakeholders involved in malaria containment, the disease burden of malaria has dramatically decreased in many malaria-endemic countries in recent years. Some decades after the past efforts of the global malaria eradication program, malaria elimination has again featured on the global health agenda. While risk distribution modeling and a mapping approach are effective tools to assist with the efficient allocation of limited health-care resources, these methods need some adjustment and reexamination in accordance with changes occurring in relation to malaria elimination. Limited available data, fine-scale data inaccessibility (for example, household or individual case data), and the lack of reliable data due to inefficiencies within the routine surveillance system, make it difficult to create reliable risk maps for decision-makers or health-care practitioners in the field. Furthermore, the risk of malaria may dynamically change due to various factors such as the progress of containment interventions and environmental changes. To address the complex and dynamic nature of situations in low-to-moderate malaria transmission settings, we built a spatiotemporal model of a standardized morbidity ratio (SMR) of malaria incidence, calculated through annual parasite incidence, using routinely reported surveillance data in combination with environmental indices such as remote sensing data, and the non-environmental regional containment status, to create fine-scale risk maps. A hierarchical Bayesian frame was employed to fit the transitioning malaria risk data onto the map. The model was set to estimate the SMRs of every study location at specific time intervals within its uncertainty range. Using the spatial interpolation of estimated SMRs at village level, we created fine-scale maps of two provinces in western Cambodia at specific time intervals. The maps presented different patterns of malaria risk distribution at specific time intervals. Moreover, the visualized weights estimated using the risk model, and the structure of the routine surveillance network, represent the transitional complexities emerging from ever-changing regional endemic situations.
由于参与疟疾控制的众多利益相关者付出了大量相关努力,近年来许多疟疾流行国家的疟疾疾病负担已大幅下降。在过去全球疟疾根除计划努力开展数十年后,疟疾消除再次成为全球卫生议程的重点。虽然风险分布建模和制图方法是协助有效分配有限卫生保健资源的有效工具,但这些方法需要根据疟疾消除方面出现的变化进行一些调整和重新审视。现有数据有限、难以获取精细尺度数据(例如家庭或个人病例数据)以及常规监测系统效率低下导致缺乏可靠数据,使得难以在实地为决策者或卫生保健从业者创建可靠的风险地图。此外,疟疾风险可能因各种因素而动态变化,如控制干预措施的进展和环境变化。为应对低至中度疟疾传播环境中情况的复杂和动态性质,我们构建了一个疟疾发病率标准化发病比(SMR)的时空模型,该模型通过年度寄生虫发病率计算得出,使用常规报告的监测数据并结合环境指标(如遥感数据)以及非环境区域控制状况,以创建精细尺度的风险地图。采用分层贝叶斯框架将不断变化的疟疾风险数据拟合到地图上。该模型设定为在其不确定性范围内估计每个研究地点在特定时间间隔的SMR。通过对村庄层面估计的SMR进行空间插值,我们在特定时间间隔创建了柬埔寨西部两个省份的精细尺度地图。这些地图呈现了特定时间间隔内不同的疟疾风险分布模式。此外,使用风险模型估计的可视化权重以及常规监测网络的结构,代表了不断变化的区域流行情况所产生的过渡复杂性。