Liu Longgui, Sun Mao
Institute of Fluid Mechanics, Beijing University of Aeronautics & Astronautics, Beijing, 100191, China.
Institute of Fluid Mechanics, Beijing University of Aeronautics & Astronautics, Beijing, 100191, China.
J Theor Biol. 2018 Jan 21;437:45-50. doi: 10.1016/j.jtbi.2017.10.014. Epub 2017 Oct 13.
The added mass forces of three-dimensional (3D) flapping wings of some representative insects, and the accuracy of the often used simple two-dimensional (2D) method, are studied. The added mass force of a flapping wing is calculated by both 3D and 2D methods, and the total aerodynamic force of the wing is calculated by the CFD method. Our findings are as following. The added mass force has a significant contribution to the total aerodynamic force of the flapping wings during and near the stroke reversals, and the shorter the stroke amplitude is, the larger the added mass force becomes. Thus the added mass force could not be neglected when using the simple models to estimate the aerodynamics force, especially for insects with relatively small stroke amplitudes. The accuracy of the often used simple 2D method is reasonably good: when the aspect ratio of the wing is greater than about 3.3, error in the added mass force calculation due to the 2D assumption is less than 9%; even when the aspect ratio is 2.8 (approximately the smallest for an insect), the error is no more than 13%.
研究了一些具有代表性昆虫的三维(3D)扑翼的附加质量力,以及常用的简单二维(2D)方法的准确性。通过三维和二维方法计算扑翼的附加质量力,并通过计算流体力学(CFD)方法计算翅膀的总气动力。我们的研究结果如下。在冲程反转期间及附近,附加质量力对扑翼的总气动力有显著贡献,冲程幅度越短,附加质量力越大。因此,在使用简单模型估算气动力时,附加质量力不可忽略,特别是对于冲程幅度相对较小的昆虫。常用的简单二维方法的准确性相当不错:当翅膀的展弦比大于约3.3时,由于二维假设导致的附加质量力计算误差小于9%;即使展弦比为2.8(大约是昆虫的最小展弦比),误差也不超过13%。