Institute of Health and Social Sciences, Molde University College, Molde, Norway.
Centre for Forensic Psychiatry, Oslo University Hospital, Molde, Norway.
J Clin Nurs. 2018 Feb;27(3-4):e611-e622. doi: 10.1111/jocn.14108. Epub 2017 Dec 4.
To gain insight into mental health staff's perception of writing progress notes in an acute and subacute psychiatric ward context.
The nursing process structures nursing documentation. Progress notes are intended to be an evaluation of a patient's nursing diagnoses, interventions and outcomes. Within this template, a patient's status and the care provided are to be recorded. The therapeutic nurse-patient relationship is recognised as a key component of psychiatric care today. At the same time, the biomedical model remains strong. Research literature exploring nursing staff's experiences with writing progress notes in psychiatric contexts, and especially the space given to staff-patient relations, is sparse.
Qualitative design.
Focus group interviews with mental health staff working in one acute and one subacute psychiatric ward were conducted. Systematic text condensation, a method for transverse thematic analysis, was used.
Two main categories emerged from the analysis: the position of the professional as an expert and distant observer in the progress notes, and the weak position of professional-patient interactions in progress notes.
The participants did not perceive that the current recording model, which is based on the nursing process, supported a focus on patients' resources or reporting professional-patient interactions. This model appeared to put ward staff in an expert position in relation to patients, which made it challenging to involve patients in the recording process. Essential aspects of nursing care related to recovery and person-centred care were not prioritised for documentation.
This study contributes to the critical examination of the documentation praxis, as well as to the critical examination of the documentation tool as to what is considered important to document.
深入了解精神科医护人员在急性和亚急性精神病病房环境下撰写病程记录的看法。
护理流程构建护理文件。病程记录旨在评估患者的护理诊断、干预措施和结果。在这个模板中,要记录患者的状况和所提供的护理。治疗性的护患关系被认为是当今精神科护理的一个关键组成部分。与此同时,生物医学模式仍然强大。探索精神科护理环境中护理人员撰写病程记录的经验,特别是记录护患关系的空间的研究文献稀缺。
定性设计。
对在一家急性和一家亚急性精神病病房工作的精神科医护人员进行焦点小组访谈。采用了一种用于横向主题分析的系统文本压缩方法。
分析产生了两个主要类别:专业人员在病程记录中作为专家和疏远观察者的立场,以及专业人员与患者互动在病程记录中的弱势地位。
参与者认为,当前基于护理流程的记录模式并不支持关注患者的资源或报告专业人员与患者的互动。这种模式似乎使病房工作人员在与患者的关系中处于专家地位,这使得让患者参与记录过程具有挑战性。与康复和以患者为中心的护理相关的护理的基本方面没有被优先记录。
这项研究有助于对记录实践进行批判性检查,以及对记录工具进行批判性检查,以确定什么是重要的记录内容。