Pavlacky David C, Lukacs Paul M, Blakesley Jennifer A, Skorkowsky Robert C, Klute David S, Hahn Beth A, Dreitz Victoria J, George T Luke, Hanni David J
Bird Conservancy of the Rockies, Brighton, Colorado, United States of America.
Wildlife Biology Program, Department of Ecosystem and Conservation Sciences, W.A. Franke College of Forestry and Conservation, University of Montana, Missoula, Montana, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2017 Oct 24;12(10):e0185924. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0185924. eCollection 2017.
Monitoring is an essential component of wildlife management and conservation. However, the usefulness of monitoring data is often undermined by the lack of 1) coordination across organizations and regions, 2) meaningful management and conservation objectives, and 3) rigorous sampling designs. Although many improvements to avian monitoring have been discussed, the recommendations have been slow to emerge in large-scale programs. We introduce the Integrated Monitoring in Bird Conservation Regions (IMBCR) program designed to overcome the above limitations. Our objectives are to outline the development of a statistically defensible sampling design to increase the value of large-scale monitoring data and provide example applications to demonstrate the ability of the design to meet multiple conservation and management objectives. We outline the sampling process for the IMBCR program with a focus on the Badlands and Prairies Bird Conservation Region (BCR 17). We provide two examples for the Brewer's sparrow (Spizella breweri) in BCR 17 demonstrating the ability of the design to 1) determine hierarchical population responses to landscape change and 2) estimate hierarchical habitat relationships to predict the response of the Brewer's sparrow to conservation efforts at multiple spatial scales. The collaboration across organizations and regions provided economy of scale by leveraging a common data platform over large spatial scales to promote the efficient use of monitoring resources. We designed the IMBCR program to address the information needs and core conservation and management objectives of the participating partner organizations. Although it has been argued that probabilistic sampling designs are not practical for large-scale monitoring, the IMBCR program provides a precedent for implementing a statistically defensible sampling design from local to bioregional scales. We demonstrate that integrating conservation and management objectives with rigorous statistical design and analyses ensures reliable knowledge about bird populations that is relevant and integral to bird conservation at multiple scales.
监测是野生动物管理与保护的重要组成部分。然而,监测数据的有效性常常因以下几点不足而受到影响:1)各组织和地区之间缺乏协调;2)缺乏有意义的管理与保护目标;3)抽样设计不够严谨。尽管已经讨论了许多改进鸟类监测的方法,但相关建议在大规模项目中的实施进展缓慢。我们推出了鸟类保护区域综合监测(IMBCR)计划,旨在克服上述限制。我们的目标是概述一种具有统计学依据的抽样设计的开发过程,以提高大规模监测数据的价值,并提供实例应用,展示该设计满足多种保护和管理目标的能力。我们概述了IMBCR计划的抽样过程,重点是荒地和草原鸟类保护区域(BCR 17)。我们提供了两个关于BCR 17地区布鲁尔麻雀(Spizella breweri)的例子,展示了该设计的能力:1)确定种群对景观变化的分层响应;2)估计分层栖息地关系,以预测布鲁尔麻雀在多个空间尺度上对保护措施的响应。各组织和地区之间的合作通过在大空间尺度上利用共同的数据平台实现了规模经济,从而促进了监测资源的有效利用。我们设计IMBCR计划以满足参与的合作伙伴组织的信息需求以及核心保护和管理目标。尽管有人认为概率抽样设计对于大规模监测不实用,但IMBCR计划为从地方到生物区域尺度实施具有统计学依据的抽样设计提供了一个范例。我们证明,将保护和管理目标与严谨的统计设计及分析相结合,可确保获得与多尺度鸟类保护相关且不可或缺的、关于鸟类种群的可靠知识。