Richards Derek
Department of Public Health, NHS Forth Valley and Centre for Evidence-based Dentistry, Dental Health Services Research Unit, Dundee Dental Hospital and School Dundee University, Dundee.
Evid Based Dent. 2017 Oct 27;18(3):70. doi: 10.1038/sj.ebd.6401250.
Data sourcesPubMed, Embase, Scopus, China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Ichushi-web, Biblioteca Virtual en Salud Espana (BVSE) and Biblioteca Virtual em Saude (BVS) databases. There were no limits on language or publication dates.Study selectionTwo reviewers selected prospective clinical studies investigating SDF treatment for caries prevention in children.Data extraction and synthesisData was abstracted independently by two reviewers and risk of bias assessed. Meta-analysis was performed on studies in which the caries-arresting rate using 38% SDF solution on primary teeth could be obtained or calculated.ResultsNineteen studies were included; 16 were conducted in the primary dentition and three in permanent dentition. Fourteen studies used 38% SDF, three 30% SDF, and two 10% SDF. Eight studies using 38% SDF contributed to a meta-analysis and the overall proportion of arrested caries was 81% (95% CI; 68-89%). Percentage reductions were also calculated for 6,12,18,24 and >30 months. Arrested carious lesions stained black but no other adverse effects were reported.ConclusionsSDF commonly used at a high concentration (38%, 44,800ppm fluoride) is effective in arresting caries among children. There is no consensus on its number and frequency of application to arrest caries. Further studies are necessary to develop evidence-based guidelines on its use in children.
数据来源
PubMed、Embase、Scopus、中国知网(CNKI)、日本医学中央杂志网络版(Ichushi-web)、西班牙虚拟健康图书馆(Biblioteca Virtual en Salud Espana,BVSE)和虚拟健康图书馆(Biblioteca Virtual em Saude,BVS)数据库。对语言和出版日期没有限制。
研究选择
两名评审员选择了调查SDF用于预防儿童龋齿的前瞻性临床研究。
数据提取与综合
两名评审员独立提取数据并评估偏倚风险。对能够获得或计算出使用38% SDF溶液治疗乳牙龋齿抑制率的研究进行荟萃分析。
结果
纳入19项研究;16项在乳牙列进行,3项在恒牙列进行。14项研究使用38% SDF,3项使用30% SDF,2项使用10% SDF。8项使用38% SDF的研究纳入荟萃分析,龋齿抑制的总体比例为81%(95%CI:68 - 89%)。还计算了6、12、18、24和>30个月时的龋齿减少百分比。龋齿病变被染成黑色,但未报告其他不良反应。
结论
常用的高浓度(38%,氟含量44800ppm)SDF对儿童龋齿抑制有效。关于其抑制龋齿的应用次数和频率尚无共识。有必要进一步开展研究以制定基于证据的儿童使用指南。