Wall Emma C, Mukaka Mavuto, Denis Brigitte, Mlozowa Veronica S, Msukwa Malango, Kasambala Khumbo, Nyrienda Mulinda, Allain Theresa J, Faragher Brian, Heyderman Robert S, Lalloo David G
Malawi-Liverpool-Wellcome Trust Clinical Research Programme, Blantyre, Malawi.
Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, Pembroke Place, Liverpool, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2017 Oct 27;12(10):e0186687. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0186687. eCollection 2017.
Mortality from acute bacterial meningitis (ABM) in sub-Saharan African adults and adolescents exceeds 50%. We tested if Goal Directed Therapy (GDT) was feasible for adults and adolescents with clinically suspected ABM in Malawi.
Sequential patient cohorts of adults and adolescents with clinically suspected ABM were recruited in the emergency department of a teaching hospital in Malawi using a before/after design. Routine care was monitored in year one (P1). In year two (P2), nurses delivered protocolised GDT (rapid antibiotics, airway support, oxygenation, seizure control and fluid resuscitation) to a second cohort. The primary endpoint was composite mean number of clinical goals attained. Secondary endpoints were individual goals attained and death or disability from proven or probable ABM at day 40.
563 patients with suspected ABM were enrolled in the study; 273 were monitored in P1; 290 patients with suspected ABM received GDT in P2. 61% were male, median age 33 years and 90% were HIV co-infected. ABM was proven or probable in 132 (23%) patients. GDT attained more clinical goals compared to routine care: composite mean number of goals in P1 was 0·55 vs. 1·57 in P2 GDT (p<0·001); Death or disability by day 40 from proven or probable ABM occurred in 29/57 (51%) in P1 and 38/60 (63%) in P2 (p = 0·19).
Nurse-led GDT in a resource-constrained setting was associated with improved delivery of protocolised care. Outcome was unaffected.
www.isrctn.com ISRCTN96218197.
撒哈拉以南非洲地区成人和青少年急性细菌性脑膜炎(ABM)的死亡率超过50%。我们测试了目标导向治疗(GDT)对马拉维临床疑似ABM的成人和青少年是否可行。
采用前后对照设计,在马拉维一家教学医院的急诊科招募临床疑似ABM的成人和青少年连续患者队列。第一年(P1)监测常规护理情况。第二年(P2),护士对第二个队列实施标准化的GDT(快速使用抗生素、气道支持、给氧、控制癫痫发作和液体复苏)。主要终点是达到的临床目标的综合平均数。次要终点是达到的个体目标以及第40天时确诊或疑似ABM导致的死亡或残疾情况。
563例疑似ABM患者纳入研究;273例在P1接受监测;290例疑似ABM患者在P2接受GDT。61%为男性,中位年龄33岁,90%合并感染艾滋病毒。132例(23%)患者确诊或疑似患有ABM。与常规护理相比,GDT实现了更多临床目标:P1达到的目标综合平均数为0.55,P2 GDT为1.57(p<0.001);P1中确诊或疑似ABM导致第40天时死亡或残疾的比例为29/57(51%),P2为38/60(63%)(p = 0.19)。
在资源有限的环境中,由护士主导的GDT与改善标准化护理的实施相关。结局未受影响。
www.isrctn.com ISRCTN96218197