Claudius Ilene A, Desai Shoma, Davis Ebony, Henderson Sean
University of Southern California, Keck School of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Los Angeles, California.
West J Emerg Med. 2017 Oct;18(6):1153-1158. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2017.7.34845. Epub 2017 Sep 18.
Violence against healthcare workers in the medical setting is common and associated with both physical and psychological adversity. The objective of this study was to identify features associated with assailants to allow early identification of patients at risk for committing an assault in the healthcare setting.
We used the hospital database for reporting assaults to identify cases from July 2011 through June 2013. Medical records were reviewed for the assailant's (patient's) past medical and social history, primary medical complaints, ED diagnoses, medications prescribed, presence of an involuntary psychiatric hold, prior assaultive behavior, history of reported illicit drug use, and frequency of visits to same hospital requesting prescription for pain medications. We selected matched controls at random for comparison. The primary outcome measure(s) reported are features of patients committing an assault while undergoing medical or psychiatric treatment within the medical center.
We identified 92 novel visits associated with an assault. History of an involuntary psychiatric hold was noted in 52%, history of psychosis in 49%, a history of violence in the ED on a prior visit in 45%, aggression at index visit noted in the ED chart in 64%, an involuntary hold (or consideration of) for danger to others in 61%, repeat visits for pain medication in 9%, and history of illicit drug use in 33%. Compared with matched controls, all these factors were significantly different.
Patients with obvious risk factors for assault, such as history of assault, psychosis, and involuntary psychiatric holds, have a substantially greater chance of committing an assault in the healthcare setting. These risk factors can easily be identified and greater security attention given to the patient.
在医疗环境中,针对医护人员的暴力行为很常见,且会带来身体和心理上的伤害。本研究的目的是确定与攻击者相关的特征,以便早期识别在医疗环境中有攻击风险的患者。
我们使用医院的攻击报告数据库来识别2011年7月至2013年6月期间的病例。查阅了攻击者(患者)的既往医疗和社会史、主要医疗投诉、急诊科诊断、所开药物、是否有非自愿精神科拘留、既往攻击行为史、报告的非法药物使用史以及到同一家医院要求开具止痛药处方的就诊频率。我们随机选择匹配的对照组进行比较。报告的主要结局指标是在医疗中心接受医疗或精神治疗时实施攻击行为的患者的特征。
我们确定了92次与攻击相关的新就诊病例。52%的患者有非自愿精神科拘留史,49%有精神病病史,45%的患者既往在急诊科有暴力史,64%的患者在本次就诊时急诊科病历中记录有攻击行为,61%的患者因对他人有危险而被非自愿拘留(或考虑拘留),9%的患者因止痛药多次就诊,33%的患者有非法药物使用史。与匹配的对照组相比,所有这些因素都有显著差异。
有明显攻击风险因素的患者,如攻击史、精神病和非自愿精神科拘留史,在医疗环境中实施攻击的可能性要大得多。这些风险因素很容易识别,可对患者给予更多的安全关注。