Mackintosh Margaret-Anne, Niehaus James, Taft Casey T, Marx Brian P, Grubbs Kathleen, Morland Leslie A
Dissemination and Training Division, National Center for PTSD, VA Palo Alto Health Care System, 795 Willow Road, Building 334 (NC-PTSD), Room C-130, Menlo Park, CA 94025.
Charles River Analytics, 625 Mt. Auburn Street, Cambridge, MA 02138.
Mil Med. 2017 Nov;182(11):e1941-e1949. doi: 10.7205/MILMED-D-17-00063.
Anger is a symptom of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) associated with a range of clinical and functional impairments, and may be especially prevalent among veterans with PTSD. Effective anger management therapies exist but may be undermined by poor engagement or lack of treatment availability. Finding ways to engage veterans in anger management therapy or to improve access can be helpful in improving clinical outcomes. This randomized controlled trial compared anger management treatment (AMT) with AMT augmented by a mobile application (app) system, Remote Exercises for Learning Anger and Excitation Management (RELAX).
Participants were 58 veterans enrolled in 12 sessions of either AMT alone or AMT with the RELAX system (AMT + RELAX). The RELAX system includes the RELAX app, a wearable heart rate monitor, a remote server, and a web-based therapist interface. RELAX allows the user to practice skills, monitor symptoms, and record physiological data. The server collects data on app use. A web-based interface allows the therapist to access data on between-session practice, and skills use. Measures administered at baseline, post-treatment, and 3-and 6-month follow-up include state and trait anger, dimensions of anger, PTSD, depression, interpersonal functioning, and satisfaction. We used multilevel modeling to account for the nesting of time points within participants and participants within treatment groups. Predictors were Treatment Condition (AMT + RELAX and AMT), Linear Time (baseline, post-treatment, 3-and 6-month follow-up), and Quadratic Time and Treatment Condition × Linear Time interaction. All analyses were conducted using SPSS 21 (Armonk, New York). Approval was obtained from the institutional review board.
Across groups, the treatment dropout rate was 13.8%; of those who remained in treatment, 90% received an adequate dose of treatment (10 or more sessions). There were no significant differences between groups on attendance or treatment completion. Participants in both treatments demonstrated statistically significant and clinically meaningful reductions in anger severity and significant post-treatment reductions in PTSD. Veterans did not report significant changes in depression or interpersonal functioning. Veterans in the AMT + RELAX group reported spending significantly less time on homework assignments, and they rated the AMT + RELAX app as helpful and easy to use, with these ratings improving over time.
Findings suggest that AMT + RELAX was beneficial in reducing anger symptoms and promoting efficient use of the between-session practice; however, AMT + RELAX did not outperform AMT. This study is an important contribution as it is one of the first randomized controlled trials to study the efficacy of a technology-enhanced, evidence-based psychotherapy for anger management. Findings are limited because of small sample size and modifications to the technology during the trial. However, the results highlight the possible benefits of mobile app-supported treatment, including increasing the accessibility of treatment, lowering therapist workload, reducing costs of treatment, reducing practice time, and enabling new activities and types of treatments. This study presents preliminary evidence that mobile apps can be a valuable addition to treatment for patients with anger difficulties. Future research should evaluate how much therapist involvement is needed to support anger management.
愤怒是创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的一种症状,与一系列临床和功能损害相关,在患有PTSD的退伍军人中可能尤为普遍。现有的有效愤怒管理疗法可能会因参与度低或缺乏治疗途径而受到影响。找到让退伍军人参与愤怒管理疗法或改善治疗途径的方法,可能有助于改善临床结果。这项随机对照试验比较了愤怒管理治疗(AMT)与通过移动应用程序(应用)系统增强的AMT,即远程学习愤怒与兴奋管理练习(RELAX)。
参与者为58名退伍军人,他们参加了12节单独的AMT课程或AMT与RELAX系统(AMT + RELAX)的课程。RELAX系统包括RELAX应用程序、可穿戴心率监测器、远程服务器和基于网络的治疗师界面。RELAX允许用户练习技能、监测症状并记录生理数据。服务器收集应用程序使用数据。基于网络的界面允许治疗师访问疗程间练习和技能使用的数据。在基线、治疗后以及3个月和6个月随访时进行的测量包括状态和特质愤怒、愤怒维度PTSD、抑郁、人际功能和满意度。我们使用多层次模型来考虑参与者内时间点的嵌套以及治疗组内参与者的嵌套。预测因素为治疗条件(AMT + RELAX和AMT)、线性时间(基线、治疗后、3个月和6个月随访)、二次时间以及治疗条件×线性时间交互作用。所有分析均使用SPSS 21(纽约州阿蒙克)进行。获得了机构审查委员会的批准。
各治疗组的治疗退出率为13.8%;在继续接受治疗的患者中,90%接受了足够剂量的治疗(10节或更多节课程)。两组在出勤率或治疗完成率方面无显著差异。两种治疗方法的参与者在愤怒严重程度上均有统计学显著且具有临床意义的降低,并且在治疗后PTSD也有显著降低。退伍军人在抑郁或人际功能方面未报告有显著变化。AMT + RELAX组的退伍军人报告称花在家庭作业上的时间显著减少,他们对AMT + RELAX应用程序的评价是有帮助且易于使用,并且这些评价随着时间推移有所提高。
研究结果表明,AMT + RELAX在减轻愤怒症状和促进疗程间练习的有效利用方面是有益的;然而,AMT + RELAX并未优于AMT。这项研究是一项重要贡献,因为它是首批研究技术增强的循证心理治疗对愤怒管理疗效的随机对照试验之一。由于样本量小以及试验期间对技术的修改,研究结果存在局限性。然而,结果突出了移动应用程序支持治疗的潜在益处,包括增加治疗的可及性、降低治疗师工作量、降低治疗成本、减少练习时间以及实现新的活动和治疗类型。这项研究提供了初步证据,表明移动应用程序可为有愤怒问题的患者治疗增添价值。未来研究应评估支持愤怒管理需要多少治疗师参与。