Ter Harmsel Janna F, Noordzij Matthijs L, van der Pol Thimo M, Swinkels Lise T A, Goudriaan Anna E, Popma Arne
Forensic Mental Healthcare, Inforsa, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Psychology, Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute, Amsterdam UMC, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Front Psychol. 2023 Mar 10;14:983286. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.983286. eCollection 2023.
Preventing and reducing violence is of high importance for both individuals and society. However, the overall efficacy of current treatment interventions aimed at reducing aggressive behavior is limited. New technological-based interventions may enhance treatment outcomes, for instance by facilitating out-of-session practice and providing just-in-time support. Therefore, the aim of this study was to assess the effects of the Sense-IT biocueing app as an addition to aggression regulation therapy (ART) on interoceptive awareness, emotion regulation, and aggressive behavior among forensic outpatients.
A combination of methods was used. Quantitatively, a pretest-posttest design was applied to explore group changes in aggression, emotion regulation, and anger bodily sensations associated with the combination of biocueing intervention and ART. Measures were assessed at pretest, after 4 weeks posttest, and after one-month follow-up. During the 4 weeks, a single-case experimental ABA design was applied for each participant. Biocueing was added in the intervention phase. During all phases anger, aggressive thoughts, aggressive behavior, behavioral control, and physical tension were assessed twice a day, and heart rate was measured continuously. Qualitative information regarding interoceptive awareness, coping, and aggression was collected at posttest. 25 forensic outpatients participated.
A significant decrease in self-reported aggression was found between pre- and posttest. Furthermore, three-quarters of participants reported increased interoceptive awareness associated with the biocueing intervention. However, the repeated ambulatory measurements of the single-case experimental designs (SCEDs) did not indicate a clear effect favoring the addition of biocueing. On group level, no significant effects were found. On the individual level, effects favoring the intervention were only found for two participants. Overall, effect sizes were small.
Biocueing seems a helpful addition to increase interoceptive awareness among forensic outpatients. However, not all patients benefit from the current intervention and, more specifically, from its behavioral support component aimed at enhancing emotion regulation. Future studies should therefore focus on increasing usability, tailoring the intervention to individual needs, and on integration into therapy. Individual characteristics associated with effective support by a biocueing intervention should be further investigated, as the use of personalized and technological-based treatment interventions is expected to increase in the coming years.
预防和减少暴力行为对个人和社会都至关重要。然而,目前旨在减少攻击行为的治疗干预措施的总体效果有限。基于新技术的干预措施可能会提高治疗效果,例如通过促进疗程外练习并提供即时支持。因此,本研究的目的是评估Sense-IT生物提示应用程序作为攻击调节疗法(ART)的补充,对法医门诊患者的内感受性觉知、情绪调节和攻击行为的影响。
采用了多种方法相结合。在定量方面,采用前测-后测设计来探究生物提示干预与ART相结合后,攻击行为、情绪调节和与愤怒相关的身体感觉方面的组内变化。在测试前、测试后4周以及1个月随访后进行测量。在这4周内,对每位参与者采用单病例实验ABA设计。在干预阶段添加生物提示。在所有阶段,每天对愤怒、攻击思维、攻击行为、行为控制和身体紧张程度进行两次评估,并持续测量心率。在测试后收集有关内感受性觉知、应对方式和攻击行为的定性信息。25名法医门诊患者参与了研究。
在前测和后测之间,自我报告的攻击行为显著减少。此外,四分之三的参与者报告称与生物提示干预相关的内感受性觉知有所增强。然而,单病例实验设计(SCEDs)的重复动态测量并未表明添加生物提示有明显效果。在组水平上,未发现显著影响。在个体水平上,仅在两名参与者中发现了有利于干预的效果。总体而言,效应量较小。
生物提示似乎有助于提高法医门诊患者的内感受性觉知。然而,并非所有患者都能从当前干预措施中受益,更具体地说,不能从其旨在增强情绪调节的行为支持部分受益。因此未来的研究应侧重于提高可用性,根据个体需求调整干预措施,并将其融入治疗中。随着未来几年基于个性化和技术的治疗干预措施的使用预计会增加,应进一步研究与生物提示干预有效支持相关的个体特征。