Morales W J, O'Brien W F, Knuppel R A, Gaylord S, Hayes P
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of South Florida College of Medicine, Tampa.
Obstet Gynecol. 1989 Jan;73(1):107-10.
The effect of birth order, presentation, and mode of delivery on neonatal outcome in nondiscordant twin gestations under 1500 g was investigated. All neonates had echoencephalograms performed by the fourth day of life to diagnose the presence and severity of intraventricular hemorrhage. One hundred fifty-six sets of twins were included in the study, of which 59 were in a vertex/vertex presentation, 59 in vertex/nonvertex presentation, and 38 with twin A in a nonvertex presentation. Second twins were characterized by a higher incidence of respiratory distress syndrome (RDS): 66 versus 54% (P less than .05), and severe grades of intraventricular hemorrhage: 30 versus 19% (P less than .01). For vertex/vertex twins, cesarean delivery did not result in improved outcome. Rather, the incidence of RDS was significantly increased in neonates from this group delivered by cesarean birth: 67 versus 46% (P less than .01). Among twins in which at least one of the fetuses was in a nonvertex presentation, those born via cesarean delivery demonstrated a lower incidence of both severe grades of intraventricular hemorrhage and mortality. However, after multivariate analysis to correct for differences in birth weight between the groups, no advantage for cesarean delivery could be demonstrated. Therefore, differences in birth weight, rather than in mode of delivery, accounted for the differences in the neonatal outcome of nonvertex-presenting twins.
研究了出生顺序、胎位及分娩方式对体重低于1500g的非双胎输血综合征双胎妊娠新生儿结局的影响。所有新生儿在出生后第4天进行了脑超声检查,以诊断脑室内出血的存在及严重程度。本研究纳入了156对双胞胎,其中59对为头先露/头先露胎位,59对为头先露/非头先露胎位,38对中双胞胎A为非头先露胎位。第二个出生的双胞胎呼吸窘迫综合征(RDS)的发生率较高:分别为66%和54%(P<0.05),重度脑室内出血的发生率也较高:分别为30%和19%(P<0.01)。对于头先露/头先露胎位的双胞胎,剖宫产并未改善结局。相反,剖宫产出生的该组新生儿RDS的发生率显著增加:分别为67%和46%(P<0.01)。在至少有一个胎儿为非头先露胎位的双胞胎中,剖宫产出生的新生儿重度脑室内出血和死亡率的发生率较低。然而,在进行多因素分析以校正各组间出生体重差异后,未显示出剖宫产有优势。因此,非头先露胎位双胞胎的新生儿结局差异是由出生体重差异而非分娩方式差异导致的。