Fragkouli Kleio, Al Hakeem Eyad, Bulut Ozgur, Simmons Tal
Department of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, University of Ioannina, Greece.
International Committee of the Red Cross, Lebanon.
J Forensic Leg Med. 2018 Jan;53:1-12. doi: 10.1016/j.jflm.2017.10.004. Epub 2017 Oct 5.
Pig half-carcasses were shot in scapulae, ribs and mandibles with either 0.243 hunting rifle using high velocity expanding ammunition (N = 30) or AK47 using full metal jacketed (FMJ) ammunition (N = 12) from a range of either 5 or 20 m. Fracture patterns related to distance of fire and ammunition type were compared on de-fleshed, macerated, and reconstructed bones. For expanding ammunition, location of fracture on ribs affected the resulting pattern. Scapulae shot from 5 m presented a comminuted pattern different from those shot from 20 m. Mandibles shot from 20 m showed a characteristic radiating pattern at entrance with the opposite ramus un-fractured; those shot from 5 m exhibited fractures to both rami. Using decision tree analysis provided accuracies of 93.8% for scapulae and 87.5% for mandibles. For FMJ, no distance dependent fracture differences were apparent in any bone. Decision tree analysis facilitated the interpretation of fracture patterns caused by projectile trauma.
使用0.243口径猎枪搭配高速扩张型弹药(N = 30)或AK47搭配全金属被甲(FMJ)弹药(N = 12),在5米或20米的距离向猪的半胴体的肩胛骨、肋骨和下颌骨射击。在去除肌肉、浸软并重建后的骨头上,比较与射击距离和弹药类型相关的骨折模式。对于扩张型弹药,肋骨上的骨折位置会影响最终的模式。从5米处射击的肩胛骨呈现出与从20米处射击不同的粉碎模式。从20米处射击的下颌骨在入口处呈现出特征性的放射状模式,对侧下颌支未骨折;从5米处射击的下颌骨两侧下颌支均骨折。使用决策树分析,肩胛骨的准确率为93.8%,下颌骨的准确率为87.5%。对于全金属被甲弹药,在任何骨骼中均未发现明显的距离依赖性骨折差异。决策树分析有助于解释投射物创伤导致的骨折模式。