Shirakawa T, Kusaka Y, Fujimura N, Goto S, Kato M, Heki S, Morimoto K
Department of Hygiene and Preventive Medicine, Medical School, Osaka University, Japan.
Chest. 1989 Jan;95(1):29-37. doi: 10.1378/chest.95.1.29.
Eight asthmatic patients who had no history of asthma before starting work in a hard-metal plant and eight control subjects (three atopic, three nonatopic asthmatic, and two normal volunteers) without a history of exposure to hard metal dust were subjected to provocation tests, skin tests, radioallergosorbent tests (RAST) and Farr test with cobalt. Four of the eight patients were atopic, and seven showed bronchial hyperresponsiveness to methacholine (BHR). Patch and intradermal skin tests with cobalt chloride (CoCl2) could not discriminate the patients from control subjects. All patients had positive reactions to CoCl2 in the provocation tests; two developed immediate asthmatic reaction (IAR), four late asthmatic reaction (LAR), and two dual asthmatic reaction (DAR), while the control subjects showed no reaction. Evidence of specific IgE antibodies to cobalt-conjugated human serum albumin (Co-HSA) was presented by four patients (RAST score greater than 2) based on comparison of serum samples from 60 asthmatic patients and 25 asymptomatic workers in the same plant. Positive serum samples selectively bound 57Co, and the test was blocked by nonlabled cobalt sulfate (CoSO4). These findings suggest the development of hard metal-induced asthma from cobalt sensitivity.
八名在硬质合金厂开始工作前无哮喘病史的哮喘患者和八名无接触硬质金属粉尘病史的对照受试者(三名特应性、三名非特应性哮喘患者和两名正常志愿者)接受了激发试验、皮肤试验、放射变应原吸附试验(RAST)和钴的Farr试验。八名患者中有四名是特应性的,七名对乙酰甲胆碱表现出支气管高反应性(BHR)。用氯化钴(CoCl2)进行的斑贴试验和皮内皮肤试验无法区分患者和对照受试者。所有患者在激发试验中对CoCl2均有阳性反应;两名出现速发型哮喘反应(IAR),四名出现迟发型哮喘反应(LAR),两名出现双相哮喘反应(DAR),而对照受试者无反应。基于对同一工厂60名哮喘患者和25名无症状工人血清样本的比较,四名患者呈现出针对钴结合人血清白蛋白(Co-HSA)的特异性IgE抗体证据(RAST评分大于2)。阳性血清样本选择性结合57Co,且该试验被未标记的硫酸钴(CoSO4)阻断。这些发现提示由钴敏感性导致了硬质金属诱发的哮喘。