Chen R T, Goldbaum G M, Wassilak S G, Markowitz L E, Orenstein W A
Division of Immunization, Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, GA.
Am J Epidemiol. 1989 Jan;129(1):173-82. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a115106.
In 1985, 69 secondary cases, all in one generation, occurred in an Illinois high school after exposure to a vigorously coughing index case. The school's 1,873 students had a pre-outbreak vaccination level of 99.7% by school records. The authors studied the mode of transmission and the risk factors for disease in this unusual outbreak. There were no school assemblies and little or no air recirculation during the schooldays that exposure occurred. Contact interviews were completed with 58 secondary cases (84%); only 11 secondary cases (19%) of these may have had exposure to the index case in the classrooms, buses, or out of school. With the use of the Reed-Frost epidemic model, only 22-65% of the secondary cases were likely to have had at least one person-to-person contact with the index case during class exchanges, suggesting that this mode of transmission alone could not explain this outbreak. A comparison of the first 45 cases and 90 matched controls suggested that cases were less likely than controls to have provider-verifiable school vaccination records (odds ratio (OR) = 8.1) and more likely to have been vaccinated at less than age 12 months (OR = 8.6) or at age 12-14 months (OR = 7.0). Despite high vaccination levels, explosive measles outbreaks may occur in secondary schools due to 1) airborne measles transmission, 2) high contact rates, 3) inaccurate school vaccination records, or 4) inadequate immunity from vaccinations at younger ages.
1985年,伊利诺伊州一所高中的一名有剧烈咳嗽症状的首例病例导致69例二代病例出现,且均为同一代人。根据学校记录,该校1873名学生在疫情爆发前的疫苗接种率为99.7%。作者研究了此次不同寻常的疫情爆发中的传播方式和疾病风险因素。在首例病例接触期间的上课日,学校没有举行集会,空气流通很少或几乎没有。对58例二代病例(84%)完成了接触者访谈;其中只有11例二代病例(19%)可能在教室、公交车上或校外接触过首例病例。运用里德 - 弗罗斯特疫情模型,只有22% - 65%的二代病例在课堂交流期间可能至少与首例病例有过一次人际接触,这表明仅这种传播方式无法解释此次疫情爆发。对前45例病例和90例匹配对照的比较表明,病例比对照更不可能有经提供者核实的学校疫苗接种记录(比值比(OR)= 8.1),更有可能在12个月龄以下(OR = 8.6)或12 - 14个月龄时接种过疫苗(OR = 7.0)。尽管疫苗接种率很高,但由于1)麻疹空气传播、2)高接触率、3)学校疫苗接种记录不准确或4)幼儿期疫苗接种产生的免疫力不足,中学仍可能发生麻疹爆发疫情。