Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research (NIVEL), Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research (NIVEL), Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Health Policy. 2018 Jan;122(1):36-43. doi: 10.1016/j.healthpol.2017.10.005. Epub 2017 Nov 6.
This paper aims to support the implementation of patient-centered care for people with multimorbidity in Europe, by providing insight into ways in which patient-centeredness is currently shaped in integrated care programs for people with multimorbidity in European countries.
In 2014, expert organizations in 31 European countries identified 200 integrated care practices ('programs') in 25 countries of which 123 were included in our study. Managers of 112 programs from 24 countries completed a questionnaire about characteristics and results of the program, including questions on elements of patient-centeredness. Eight programs that were considered especially innovative or promising were analyzed in depth.
Programs used various methodologies to involve people with multimorbidity in decision-making, such as motivational interviewing and narrative counseling techniques. In 79 programs individual care plans were developed together with patients. Few programs had already been systematically evaluated, but in one program it was shown that working with individual care plans based on patients' goals and resources resulted in increased patient satisfaction with care. Various barriers to deliver patient-centered care were reported, including inadequate knowledge and skills of both patients and professionals.
In many European countries innovative approaches are applied to increase patient-centeredness of care for people with multimorbidity. To assess their potential benefits and conditions for implementation, thorough process and outcome evaluations of programs are urgently needed.
本文旨在为欧洲实施以患者为中心的多病共存患者照护提供支持,深入了解当前欧洲各国多病共存综合照护项目中以患者为中心的照护模式。
2014 年,31 个欧洲国家的专家组织在 25 个国家确定了 200 项综合照护实践(“项目”),其中 123 项被纳入本研究。来自 24 个国家的 112 个项目的管理人员完成了一份关于项目特点和结果的问卷,其中包括患者为中心的相关问题。对 8 个被认为特别创新或有前途的项目进行了深入分析。
项目采用了各种方法让多病共存患者参与决策,如动机访谈和叙事咨询技巧。在 79 个项目中,与患者一起制定了个性化的护理计划。很少有项目进行过系统评估,但在一个项目中,基于患者目标和资源制定个性化护理计划可提高患者对护理的满意度。报告了实施以患者为中心的护理存在各种障碍,包括患者和专业人员知识和技能不足。
在许多欧洲国家,创新性方法被应用于提高多病共存患者的护理以患者为中心程度。为评估其潜在益处和实施条件,迫切需要对项目进行全面的过程和结果评估。