Mokaya Evans, Mugoya Isaac, Raburu Jane, Shimp Lora
USAID's Maternal and Child Survival Program (MCSP)/John Snow, Inc (JSI), Nairobi, Kenya.
Kisumu County Health Team/Ministry of Health, Kisumu, Kenya.
Pan Afr Med J. 2017 Sep 13;28:24. doi: 10.11604/pamj.2017.28.24.12631. eCollection 2017.
In Kenya, failure to complete immunization schedules by children who previously accessed immunization services is an obstacle to ensuring that children are fully immunized. Home visit approaches used to track defaulting children have not been successful in reducing the drop-out rate.
This study tested the use of phone contacts as an approach for tracking immunization defaulters in twelve purposively-selected facilities in three districts of western Kenya. For nine months, children accessing immunization services in the facilities were tracked and caregivers were asked their reasons for defaulting.
In all of the facilities, caregiver phone ownership was above 80%. In 11 of the 12 facilities, defaulter rates between pentavalent1 and pentavalent3 vaccination doses reduced significantly to within the acceptable level of < 10%. Caregivers provided reliable contact information and health workers positively perceived phone-based defaulter communications. Tracking a defaulter required on average 2 minutes by voice and Ksh 6 ($ 0.07). Competing tasks and concerns about vaccinating sick children and side-effects were the most cited reasons for caregivers defaulting. Notably, a significant number of children categorised as defaulters had been vaccinated in a different facility (and were therefore "false defaulters").
Use of phone contacts for follow-up is a feasible and cost-effective method for tracking defaulters. This approach should complement traditional home visits, especially for caregivers without phones. Given communication-related reasons for defaulting, it is important that immunization programs scale-up community education activities. A system for health facilities to share details of defaulting children should be established to reduce "false defaulters".
在肯尼亚,那些之前接受过免疫服务的儿童未能完成免疫接种计划,这成为确保儿童获得全面免疫的一大障碍。用于追踪未按时接种儿童的家访方法在降低辍学率方面并不成功。
本研究在肯尼亚西部三个地区的12个经过特意挑选的机构中,测试了使用电话联系来追踪未按时接种疫苗者的方法。在九个月的时间里,对在这些机构接受免疫服务的儿童进行了追踪,并询问了看护人未按时接种的原因。
在所有机构中,看护人的手机拥有率都超过了80%。在12个机构中的11个,五价疫苗1剂和五价疫苗3剂接种剂量之间的未按时接种率显著降低至可接受水平<10%以内。看护人提供了可靠的联系信息,卫生工作者对基于电话的未按时接种者沟通方式给予了积极评价。追踪一名未按时接种者平均需要2分钟语音通话时间,费用为6肯尼亚先令(0.07美元)。相互竞争的任务以及对接种患病儿童和副作用的担忧是看护人未按时接种的最常被提及的原因。值得注意的是,大量被归类为未按时接种者的儿童已在其他机构接种过疫苗(因此是“假未按时接种者”)。
使用电话联系进行随访是一种可行且具有成本效益的追踪未按时接种者的方法。这种方法应补充传统的家访,特别是对于没有电话的看护人。鉴于与沟通相关的未按时接种原因,扩大免疫计划的社区教育活动非常重要。应建立一个卫生机构共享未按时接种儿童详细信息的系统,以减少“假未按时接种者”。