Ismail Amina, Tabu Collins, Onuekwusi Iheoma, Otieno Samuel Kevin, Ademba Peter, Kamau Peter, Koki Beatrice, Ngatia Anthony, Wainaina Anthony, Davis Robert
American Red Cross, US.
Ministry of Health, EPI program.
Pan Afr Med J. 2017 Jun 22;27(Suppl 3):16. doi: 10.11604/pamj.supp.2017.27.3.11939. eCollection 2017.
A Measles rubella campaign that targeted 9 months to 14 year old children was conducted in all the 47 counties in Kenya between 16th and 24th of May 2016. Micro-planning using an android phone-based app was undertaken to map out the target population and logistics in all the counties 4 weeks to the campaign implementation instead of 6 months as per the WHO recommendation. The outcomes of the micro-planning exercise were a detailed micro-plan that served as a guide in ensuring that every eligible individual in the population was vaccinated with potent vaccine. A national Trainer of Trainers training was done to equip key officers with new knowledge and skills in developing micro-plans at all levels. The micro planning was done using a mobile phone app, the doforms that enabled data to be transmitted real time to the national level. The objective of the study was to establish whether use of mobile phone app would contribute to quality of sub national micro plans that can be used for national level planning and implementation of the campaign.
There were 9 data collection forms but only forms 1-7 were to be uploaded onto the app. Forms 8A and 9A were to be filled but were to remain at the implementation level for use intra campaign. The forms were coded; Form 1A&B, 2A, 3A, 4A, 5A, 6A, 7A, 8A and 9A The Village form (form 1A&B) captured information by household which included village names, name of head of household, cell phone contact of head of household, number of children aged 9 months to 14years in the household, possible barriers to reaching the children, appropriate vaccination strategy based on barriers identified and estimated or proposed number of teams and type. This was the main form and from this every other form picked the population figures to estimate other supplies and logistics. On advocacy, communication and social mobilization the information collected included mobile network coverage, public amenities such as churches, mosques and key partners at the local level. On human resource and cold chain supplies the information collected included number of health facilities by type, number of health workers by cadre in facilities within the village, number of vaccine carriers and icepacks by size, refrigerators and freezers. All these forms were to be uploaded onto the phone app. except form 8A, the individual team plan, which was to be used during implementation at the local level. Android phone application, doforms, was used to capture data. Training on micro planning, data entry and doforms app was conducted at National, County, Sub-county and ward levels using standardized guidelines. An interactive case study was used in all the trainings to facilitate understanding. The App was also available on Laptops through its provided web-application. The app allowed multiple users to log in concurrently. Feedback on all the variables were obtained from the team at the Ward level. The ward level team included education officers or teachers, village elders, community health workers and other community stakeholders. Only the Ward level was allowed to collect information on paper and that information was subsequently transferred to the phone-based app, doforms, by health information officers. The national, county and sub county were able to access their data from the app using a password provided by the administrator.
Real time data was received from 46 of 47 counties. One county (Marsabit) did not participate in the micro plan process. Over 97% (283/290) of the sub counties responded and shared various information via the app. Different data forms had different completion rates. There was 100% completion rate for the data on villages and target population. Much valuable information was shared but there was no time for the national and county level to interrogate and harmonize for proper implementation. The information captured during the campaign can be used for routine immunization and other community based interventions. Electronic data collection not only provided the number of children but provided the locations also where these children could be found.
Despite the limitations of time to harmonize the micro plans with the national plan, the micro planning process was a great success with 46/47 counties responding through the mobile phone app. Not only did it provide the numbers of the target children, it further provided the places where these children could be found. There was timely data transfer, data integrity, tracking, real time data visualization reporting and analysis. The app enabled real time feedback to national focal point by data entry clerks as well as enabling trouble shooting by the administrator. This ensured campaign planning was done from the lowest level to the national level.
2016年5月16日至24日,肯尼亚47个县针对9个月至14岁儿童开展了麻疹风疹疫苗接种活动。活动开展前4周,利用一款基于安卓手机的应用程序进行微观规划,以确定所有县的目标人群和后勤安排,而非按照世界卫生组织的建议在活动开展前6个月进行。微观规划的成果是一份详细的微观计划,可作为确保目标人群中的每一个符合条件的个体都接种有效疫苗的指导。开展了全国性的培训师培训,以使关键官员掌握各级制定微观计划的新知识和技能。微观规划使用一款手机应用程序doforms进行,该程序能够将数据实时传输至国家层面。本研究的目的是确定使用手机应用程序是否有助于提高可用于国家层面活动规划和实施的次国家级微观计划的质量。
共有9份数据收集表,但只有表1至表7需上传至应用程序。表8A和表9A需填写,但将保留在实施层面供活动期间使用。这些表格都进行了编码,分别为表1A&B、2A、3A、4A、5A、6A、7A、8A和9A。村庄表格(表1A&B)按家庭收集信息,包括村庄名称、户主姓名、户主手机号码、家庭中9个月至14岁儿童的数量、接触儿童可能存在的障碍、基于所确定障碍的适当疫苗接种策略以及估计或建议的团队数量和类型。这是主要表格,其他表格均据此选取人口数据来估算其他物资和后勤安排。在宣传、沟通和社会动员方面,收集的信息包括移动网络覆盖范围、当地的公共设施,如教堂、清真寺以及主要合作伙伴。在人力资源和冷链物资方面,收集的信息包括各类卫生设施的数量、村庄内各机构按干部类别划分的卫生工作者数量、不同规格的疫苗运输箱和冰袋数量、冰箱和冰柜数量。所有这些表格都需上传至手机应用程序,表8A(即个人团队计划)除外,该表格将在地方实施过程中使用。使用安卓手机应用程序doforms来收集数据。利用标准化指南在国家、县、次县和乡各级开展了微观规划、数据录入和doforms应用程序培训。所有培训均采用互动式案例研究以促进理解。该应用程序还可通过其提供的网络应用程序在笔记本电脑上使用。该应用程序允许多个用户同时登录。从乡级团队获取了所有变量的反馈。乡级团队包括教育官员或教师、村长、社区卫生工作者和其他社区利益相关者。仅允许乡级团队以纸质形式收集信息,随后由卫生信息官员将这些信息录入基于手机的应用程序doforms。国家、县和次县能够使用管理员提供的密码从应用程序中访问其数据。
从47个县中的46个县收到了实时数据。有一个县(马萨比特)未参与微观规划过程。超过97%(283/290)的次县做出了回应,并通过应用程序分享了各类信息。不同的数据表有不同的完成率。村庄和目标人群的数据完成率为100%。分享了许多有价值的信息,但国家和县级层面没有时间进行审查和协调以确保正确实施。活动期间收集的信息可用于常规免疫和其他基于社区的干预措施。电子数据收集不仅提供了儿童数量,还提供了这些儿童所在的地点。
尽管在将微观计划与国家计划进行协调方面时间有限,但微观规划过程非常成功,47个县中有46个县通过手机应用程序做出了回应。它不仅提供了目标儿童的数量,还进一步提供了这些儿童所在的地点。实现了及时的数据传输、数据完整性、跟踪、实时数据可视化报告和分析。该应用程序使数据录入员能够向国家协调中心提供实时反馈,并使管理员能够进行故障排除。这确保了从最低级别到国家层面的活动规划。