Sable-Smith Alex, Arnett Kelly R, Nowels Molly A, Colborn Kathryn, Lum Hillary D, Nowels David
University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, CO, USA.
Colorado School of Public Health, Aurora, CO, USA.
Fam Pract. 2018 May 23;35(3):307-311. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmx113.
To identify factors associated with completion of Advance Care Planning (ACP) by patients seen in primary care in developed countries. We hypothesized that the quality of primary care is associated.
We analysed respondent reported individual and healthcare utilization factors associated with the completion of ACP activities from the 2014 Commonwealth Fund International Health Policy Survey of Older Adults in 11 Countries. The primary outcome is the combined number of ACP activities completed. ACP activities included discussion of treatment preferences, documentation of healthcare wishes, or documentation of a surrogate decision maker. A quality of primary care index was calculated.
Respondents averaged 69 years old. Most were women, graduated high school, rated their income as average or higher, and rated their health as good or better. A minority reported multimorbidity, accessed the emergency department or hospital, or were informal caregivers. Out of 25530 survey respondents, 13409 (53%) reported completion of any ACP activity; 11579 (45%) had discussed treatment preferences. Generalized linear mixed model results suggest that hospitalization (rate ratio [RR] 1.18), multimorbidity (RR 1.16), informal caregiving (RR 1.13), higher education level (RR 1.14), income (RR 1.05), access to higher quality primary care (RR 1.04) and ED visits (RR 1.04) were associated with higher rates of ACP activities. Male gender (RR 0.85) and higher perceived health status (RR 0.96) were associated with lower rates.
In this international study, individuals with greater interaction with the healthcare system through hospitalization, multimorbidity, access to quality primary care and informal caregiving reported more ACP activities.
确定在发达国家接受初级保健的患者完成预先护理计划(ACP)的相关因素。我们假设初级保健质量与之相关。
我们分析了受访者报告的与ACP活动完成情况相关的个人因素和医疗保健利用因素,这些数据来自2014年英联邦基金对11个国家老年人进行的国际卫生政策调查。主要结果是完成的ACP活动的综合数量。ACP活动包括讨论治疗偏好、记录医疗保健意愿或记录替代决策者。计算了初级保健质量指数。
受访者平均年龄69岁。大多数为女性,高中毕业,将自己的收入评为平均水平或更高,将自己的健康状况评为良好或更好。少数人报告患有多种疾病、去过急诊科或医院,或是非正式护理人员。在25530名调查受访者中,13409人(53%)报告完成了任何一项ACP活动;11579人(45%)讨论过治疗偏好。广义线性混合模型结果表明,住院治疗(率比[RR]为1.18)、多种疾病(RR为1.16)、非正式护理(RR为1.13)、高等教育水平(RR为1.14)、收入(RR为1.05)、获得更高质量的初级保健(RR为1.04)和急诊就诊(RR为1.04)与更高的ACP活动率相关。男性(RR为0.85)和更高的自我感知健康状况(RR为0.96)与较低的活动率相关。
在这项国际研究中,通过住院治疗、多种疾病、获得高质量初级保健和非正式护理与医疗保健系统有更多互动的个体报告了更多的ACP活动。