Ankuda Claire K, Petterson Stephen M, Wingrove Peter, Bazemore Andrew W
Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholars Program, Family Medicine, University of Michigan Health System, Ann Arbor, Michigan
Robert Graham Center, Washington, DC.
Ann Fam Med. 2017 Jan;15(1):63-67. doi: 10.1370/afm.2002. Epub 2017 Jan 6.
Variation in end-of-life care in the United States is frequently driven by the health care system. We assessed the association of primary care physician involvement at the end of life with end-of-life care patterns.
We analyzed 2010 Medicare Part B claims data for US hospital referral regions (HRRs). The independent variable was the ratio of primary care physicians to specialist visits in the last 6 months of life. Dependent variables included the rate of hospital deaths, hospital and intensive care use in the last 6 months of life, percentage of patients seen by more than 10 physicians, and Medicare spending in the last 2 years of life. Robust linear regression analysis was used to measure the association of primary care physician involvement at the end of life with the outcome variables, adjusting for regional characteristics.
We assessed 306 HRRs, capturing 1,107,702 Medicare Part B beneficiaries with chronic disease who died. The interquartile range of the HRR ratio of primary care to specialist end-of-life visits was 0.77 to 1.21. HRRs with high vs low primary care physician involvement at the end of life had significantly different patient, population, and health system characteristics. Adjusting for these differences, HRRs with the greatest primary care physician involvement had lower Medicare spending in the last 2 years of life ($65,160 vs $69,030; = .003) and fewer intensive care unit days in the last 6 months of life (2.90 vs 4.29; <.001), but also less hospice enrollment (44.5% of decedents vs 50.4%; = .004).
Regions with greater primary care physician involvement in end-of-life care have overall less intensive end-of-life care.
美国临终关怀的差异常常由医疗保健系统驱动。我们评估了临终时初级保健医生的参与与临终关怀模式之间的关联。
我们分析了2010年美国医院转诊区域(HRR)的医疗保险B部分索赔数据。自变量是临终前6个月内初级保健医生与专科医生就诊次数的比率。因变量包括医院死亡发生率、临终前6个月内的医院和重症监护使用情况、看过10名以上医生的患者百分比以及临终前2年的医疗保险支出。采用稳健线性回归分析来衡量临终时初级保健医生的参与与结果变量之间的关联,并对区域特征进行了调整。
我们评估了306个HRR,涵盖了1107702名患有慢性病且已死亡的医疗保险B部分受益人。HRR中初级保健与专科临终就诊比率的四分位间距为0.77至1.21。临终时初级保健医生参与程度高与低的HRR在患者、人群和卫生系统特征方面存在显著差异。对这些差异进行调整后,初级保健医生参与程度最高的HRR在临终前2年的医疗保险支出较低(65160美元对69030美元;P = 0.003),在临终前6个月的重症监护病房天数较少(2.90天对4.29天;P < 0.001),但临终关怀登记人数也较少(44.5%的死者对50.4%;P = 0.004)。
在临终关怀中初级保健医生参与程度较高的地区,总体上临终关怀的强度较低。