Bousquet E, Franc N, Ha C, Purper-Ouakil D
Médecine psychologique de l'enfant et de l'adolescent (MPEA1), MPEA secteur 1, hôpital Saint-Éloi, CHU de Montpellier, 80, avenue Augustin-Fliche, 34295 Montpellier, France.
Médecine psychologique de l'enfant et de l'adolescent (MPEA1), MPEA secteur 1, hôpital Saint-Éloi, CHU de Montpellier, 80, avenue Augustin-Fliche, 34295 Montpellier, France.
Encephale. 2018 Apr;44(2):176-182. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2017.09.002. Epub 2017 Nov 17.
Child-to-parent violence is a form of family violence that is still a well-kept secret. Abused parents can be victims of different types of abuse. Children can use both physical and psychological violence such as financial threats to take control of the home. In this situation, parents often no longer dare to contradict their children by fear of triggering uncontrollable violence. Although the phenomenon recently drew the attention of the media, there is still little knowledge about its prevalence and clinical characteristics. Most families remain isolated for a long time and, even in case of consulting in a mental health setting, disclosure of the nature of the difficulties is often delayed. This article presents the specificities of these children and their clinical characteristics. It also studies the victimized parents, the entire family, and their relation to the external environment. When observing these young offenders oppositional defiant disorder, conduct disorder and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder are frequently found. The diagnosis of "conduct disorder confined to family context" defined in the ICD 10 is the most appropriate to describe them. But it is regrettable that there has currently been no study to validate it and to determine its specificity. Compared with other young children who have "classic" disruptive disorders, children involved in violence against their parents have more difficulties with affect regulation, impulse control, and interpersonal skills. These children also frequently have low self-esteem and difficulties interacting with their peers. They may be isolated and bullied. They feel more sadness than these other young people and use violence as a way to express their emotions. Within the family both girls and boys commit violence against their parents. Girls will mostly use psychological violence but can also be involved in physical aggression. The first victim of child-to-parent violence is the mother. As mothers are often more present at home and seen by their children as weaker than the father, they are seen as an "easy target". If the "classic" conduct disorder is most frequently encountered in low social status families, intra familial disruptive behavior can be observed in families from all socio economic status. With respect to the parent-child relationship in those families, there are some relevant specificities. First, the quality of communication is bad, parents and children are not intimate and the tension is permanent. Furthermore, children do not respect their parents' authority. They perceive parenting style as permissive and negligent without enough support and control, and they may want to restore a coherent authority in the family. It is important to mention that potential vulnerability factors such as older age, a history of mental illness and social isolation have been described in parents of these children. Thereby, victimized parents have all the more difficulty to stand up against their children or to cleverly adapt their authority to their behavior. Other types of inappropriate education can be the origin of the child-to-parent violence. There is a direct correlation between the high frequency of punishments and violent attitude of the children towards their parents. So, the family dynamic is characterized by an inversion of the family hierarchy, the parents' fear of violent behavior from their child, and shame expressed by the parents with regards to the nature of familial relationships. Their fear and their shame will contribute to ensuring that their child's behavior is kept secret. Finally, several factors can therefore be at the source of the development of child-to- parent violence ; this study aims to raise awareness of clinicians of this impairing and frequently hidden condition. Due to the absence of specific studies, management of intra-familial disruptive disorder is likely to be less than optimal and heterogeneous. The development of a group of targeted parental psychoeducation is a promising management technique. We will describe the basic principles of « active parental control», a programme using techniques of « non-violent resistance» to help parents cope with violence and control children's behavior. The results of this programme are still being evaluated, but preliminary results seem promising since the parents included in the pilot group have described a significant improvement in the feeling of parental competence and, notably, self-control.
儿童对父母的暴力行为是家庭暴力的一种形式,至今仍是一个鲜为人知的秘密。受虐父母可能是不同类型虐待行为的受害者。儿童可能会使用身体暴力和心理暴力,如经济威胁,来掌控家庭。在这种情况下,父母往往因害怕引发无法控制的暴力而不敢反驳自己的孩子。尽管这一现象最近引起了媒体的关注,但对其发生率和临床特征仍知之甚少。大多数家庭会长期处于孤立状态,即使在寻求心理健康咨询时,往往也会延迟透露困难的本质。本文介绍了这些儿童的特点及其临床特征。还研究了受害父母、整个家庭以及他们与外部环境的关系。观察这些青少年犯罪者时,经常会发现对立违抗障碍、品行障碍和注意力缺陷多动障碍。国际疾病分类第10版中定义的“仅限于家庭环境的品行障碍”诊断最适合描述他们。但遗憾的是,目前尚无研究对其进行验证并确定其特异性。与其他患有“典型”破坏性行为障碍的幼儿相比,参与暴力侵害父母行为的儿童在情绪调节、冲动控制和人际交往技能方面存在更多困难。这些儿童还经常自尊心较低,与同龄人交往存在困难。他们可能会被孤立和欺负。他们比其他年轻人感到更多悲伤,并将暴力作为表达情绪的一种方式。在家庭中,女孩和男孩都会对父母实施暴力。女孩大多使用心理暴力,但也可能参与身体攻击。儿童对父母暴力行为的首要受害者是母亲。由于母亲通常更多地待在家里,并且在孩子眼中比父亲更软弱,她们被视为“容易攻击的目标”。如果说“典型”的品行障碍在社会地位较低的家庭中最为常见,那么家庭内部的破坏性行为在所有社会经济地位的家庭中都能观察到。关于这些家庭中的亲子关系,有一些相关的特点。首先,沟通质量很差,父母与孩子不亲密,紧张关系持续存在。此外,孩子不尊重父母的权威。他们认为养育方式是放任和疏忽的,缺乏足够的支持和控制,他们可能想在家庭中恢复一种连贯的权威。需要指出的是,这些孩子的父母存在一些潜在的脆弱因素,如年龄较大、有精神病史和社会孤立等。因此,受害父母更难以反抗自己的孩子,或巧妙地使自己的权威适应孩子的行为。其他类型不恰当的教育可能是儿童对父母暴力行为的根源。惩罚频率与孩子对父母的暴力态度之间存在直接关联。所以,家庭动态的特点是家庭等级颠倒、父母害怕孩子的暴力行为以及父母对家庭关系本质表现出羞耻感。他们的恐惧和羞耻感会促使他们对孩子的行为保密。最后,因此有几个因素可能是儿童对父母暴力行为发展的根源;本研究旨在提高临床医生对这种有害且经常隐藏的状况的认识。由于缺乏具体研究,家庭内部破坏性行为障碍的管理可能不太理想且存在差异。开展一组有针对性的家长心理教育是一种有前景的管理技术。我们将描述“积极家长控制”的基本原则,这是一个使用“非暴力抵抗”技术来帮助家长应对暴力并控制孩子行为的项目。该项目的结果仍在评估中,但初步结果似乎很有希望,因为试点组中的家长表示家长能力感,尤其是自我控制能力有了显著改善。