Hill Brandon J, Bouris Alida, Barnett Joshua Trey, Walker Dayna
Center for Interdisciplinary Inquiry and Innovation in Sexual and Reproductive Health (Ci3), Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, The University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
Section of Family Planning and Contraceptive Research, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, The University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
Transgend Health. 2016 Jan 1;1(1):4-11. doi: 10.1089/trgh.2015.0002. eCollection 2016.
Although transgender people are currently excluded from enlistment and discharged from service based on medical and psychological fitness policies, the current mental and physical health of transgender active-duty U.S. military personnel and veterans is poorly understood. The purpose of the current study was to investigate the military histories, lifetime mental and physical health diagnoses, and transgender transition-related health of transgender active-duty service members (ADSM) and veterans. Participants were recruited through private LGBT military and veteran organizational listservs, snowball sampling, and in-person recruitment to complete an anonymous and confidential self-administered online questionnaire. A total of 106 transgender ADSM (=55) and veterans (=51) completed the questionnaire. Transgender veterans were significantly older (44 mean years vs. 29.5 mean years, =-6.23, <0.001). A greater percentage of veterans than ADSM reported depression (64.6% vs. 30.9%, =11.68, =0.001) and anxiety (41.3% vs. 18.2%, =6.54, =0.011). In addition, 15.9% of veterans versus 1.8% of ADSM (=6.53, =0.011) had been diagnosed with a substance abuse disorder. There were no significant differences in lifetime physical health conditions; however, veterans reported a higher body-mass index than ADSM (28.4 vs. 24.9, =-3.85, <0.001). For both groups, mental and physical health problems were positively correlated with age and years of military service (=0.37-0.84, <0.01). There were no significant differences between groups in transgender transition-related health. Our data represent the first descriptive statistics of lifetime mental and physical health issues among transgender ADSM and veterans. Data indicate that transgender ADSM report fewer lifetime mental and physical health problems than transgender veterans. Taken together, our findings suggest that more research, specifically among transgender ADSM, is needed to challenge the exclusion of transgender persons from U.S. military service based on the presumption of poor mental or physical health.
尽管根据医学和心理健康政策,跨性别者目前被禁止入伍且会被开除军籍,但人们对美国现役跨性别军人和退伍军人目前的身心健康状况知之甚少。本研究的目的是调查跨性别现役军人(ADSM)和退伍军人的军事经历、终生身心健康诊断以及与跨性别转变相关的健康状况。通过私人的 LGBT 军人和退伍军人组织邮件列表、滚雪球抽样以及现场招募的方式招募参与者,以完成一份匿名且保密的在线自填问卷。共有 106 名跨性别 ADSM(=55)和退伍军人(=51)完成了问卷。跨性别退伍军人的年龄显著更大(平均 44 岁 vs. 平均 29.5 岁,=-6.23,<0.001)。报告患有抑郁症的退伍军人比例高于 ADSM(64.6% vs. 30.9%,=11.68,=0.001),报告患有焦虑症的比例也更高(41.3% vs. 18.2%,=6.54,=0.011)。此外,15.9%的退伍军人被诊断患有物质使用障碍,而 ADSM 这一比例为 1.8%(=6.53,=0.011)。终生身体健康状况方面没有显著差异;然而,退伍军人报告的身体质量指数高于 ADSM(28.4 vs. 24.9,=-3.85,<0.001)。对于两组而言,身心健康问题与年龄和服役年限呈正相关(=0.37 - 0.84,<0.01)。在与跨性别转变相关的健康方面,两组之间没有显著差异。我们的数据代表了跨性别 ADSM 和退伍军人终生身心健康问题的首批描述性统计数据。数据表明,跨性别 ADSM 报告的终生身心健康问题比跨性别退伍军人少。综上所述,我们的研究结果表明,需要进行更多研究,特别是针对跨性别 ADSM 的研究,以质疑基于身心健康状况不佳的假设而将跨性别者排除在美国军队服役之外的做法。