De Tiège Alexis, Van de Peer Yves, Braeckman Johan, Tanghe Koen B
Department of Philosophy and Moral Science, Ghent University, Blandijnberg 2, 9000, Ghent, Belgium.
Department of Plant Biotechnology and Bioinformatics, VIB & Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Hist Philos Life Sci. 2017 Nov 22;40(1):6. doi: 10.1007/s40656-017-0174-x.
Although classical evolutionary theory, i.e., population genetics and the Modern Synthesis, was already implicitly 'gene-centred', the organism was, in practice, still generally regarded as the individual unit of which a population is composed. The gene-centred approach to evolution only reached a logical conclusion with the advent of the gene-selectionist or gene's eye view in the 1960s and 1970s. Whereas classical evolutionary theory can only work with (genotypically represented) fitness differences between individual organisms, gene-selectionism is capable of working with fitness differences among genes within the same organism and genome. Here, we explore the explanatory potential of 'intra-organismic' and 'intra-genomic' gene-selectionism, i.e., of a behavioural-ecological 'gene's eye view' on genetic, genomic and organismal evolution. First, we give a general outline of the framework and how it complements the-to some extent-still 'organism-centred' approach of classical evolutionary theory. Secondly, we give a more in-depth assessment of its explanatory potential for biological evolution, i.e., for Darwin's 'common descent with modification' or, more specifically, for 'historical continuity or homology with modular evolutionary change' as it has been studied by evolutionary developmental biology (evo-devo) during the last few decades. In contrast with classical evolutionary theory, evo-devo focuses on 'within-organism' developmental processes. Given the capacity of gene-selectionism to adopt an intra-organismal gene's eye view, we outline the relevance of the latter model for evo-devo. Overall, we aim for the conceptual integration between the gene's eye view on the one hand, and more organism-centred evolutionary models (both classical evolutionary theory and evo-devo) on the other.
虽然经典进化理论,即群体遗传学和现代综合理论,已经隐含地以“基因为中心”,但实际上,生物体仍然普遍被视为种群所由构成的个体单位。以基因为中心的进化方法直到20世纪60年代和70年代基因选择主义或基因视角出现时才得出合乎逻辑的结论。经典进化理论只能处理个体生物体之间(以基因型表示的)适合度差异,而基因选择主义能够处理同一生物体和基因组内基因之间的适合度差异。在这里,我们探讨“生物体内”和“基因组内”基因选择主义的解释潜力,即关于遗传、基因组和生物体进化的行为生态学“基因视角”。首先,我们概述该框架及其如何在一定程度上补充仍然以“生物体为中心”的经典进化理论方法。其次,我们更深入地评估其对生物进化的解释潜力,即对达尔文的“带有修饰的共同祖先”,或者更具体地说,对进化发育生物学(evo-devo)在过去几十年中所研究的“具有模块化进化变化的历史连续性或同源性”的解释潜力。与经典进化理论不同,evo-devo关注“生物体内”的发育过程。鉴于基因选择主义能够采用生物体内基因视角,我们概述了后者模型对evo-devo的相关性。总体而言,我们旨在一方面将基因视角与另一方面更以生物体为中心的进化模型(经典进化理论和evo-devo)进行概念整合。