Zhao Xin, Xu Yiwenjie, Fu Junjun, Maes Joseph H R
Behavior Rehabilitation Training Research Institution, School of Psychology, Northwest Normal University, Lanzhou, China.
Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Centre for Cognition, Radboud University, PO. Box 9104, Nijmegen, 6500 HE, The Netherlands.
Mem Cognit. 2018 Apr;46(3):398-409. doi: 10.3758/s13421-017-0773-5.
Previous studies examining effects of working memory (WM) updating training revealed mixed results. One factor that might modulate training gains, and possibly also transfer of those gains to non-trained cognitive tasks, is achievement motivation. In the present Studies 1 and 2, students with either a high (HAM) or low (LAM) achievement motivation completed a 14-day visuospatial WM updating training program. In Study 2, the students also performed a set of tasks measuring other executive functions and fluid intelligence prior to and after training. In both studies, the HAM students displayed a larger training gain than the LAM students. Study 2 revealed that after training, both groups showed better performance on the near-transfer but not far-transfer tasks. Importantly, the differential training gain was not associated with better post-training performance for the HAM compared to the LAM students on any of the transfer tasks. These results are taken to support a modulatory role of achievement motivation on WM training benefits, but not on transfer of those benefits to other tasks. Possible reasons for the general improvement on the near-transfer tasks and the absence of a modulatory role of achievement motivation on transfer-task performance are discussed.
以往研究工作记忆(WM)更新训练效果时,结果喜忧参半。成就动机可能是调节训练收益,以及将这些收益迁移到未训练的认知任务中的一个因素。在当前的研究1和研究2中,具有高成就动机(HAM)或低成就动机(LAM)的学生完成了一项为期14天的视觉空间WM更新训练计划。在研究2中,学生们在训练前后还进行了一系列测量其他执行功能和流体智力的任务。在两项研究中,HAM组学生比LAM组学生表现出更大的训练收益。研究2表明,训练后,两组在近迁移任务上表现更好,但在远迁移任务上并非如此。重要的是,与LAM组学生相比,HAM组学生在任何迁移任务上的差异训练收益与训练后更好的表现无关。这些结果支持了成就动机对WM训练益处的调节作用,但不支持将这些益处迁移到其他任务中的调节作用。文中讨论了近迁移任务普遍改善以及成就动机对迁移任务表现缺乏调节作用的可能原因。