Braun C M, Baribeau J M, Ethier M, Daigneault S, Proulx R
Department of Psychology, Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada.
Brain Inj. 1989 Jan-Mar;3(1):5-17. doi: 10.3109/02699058909008068.
Although several affective impairments have been demonstrated to occur following closed-head injury (CHI), deficits of the communicative function of language, particularly sentenial and suprasentential pragmatic aspects, have been suggested, but not demonstrated, to occur. This study compared 31 normals and 31 severely closed-head injured patients matched for age, sex and education. The dependent measures consisted of a facial test of emotion (FTE) and a contextual test of emotion (CTE). The former task consisted of 36 slides representing facial expressions of the six emotions demonstrated by Ekman and colleagues to be transcultural, namely, job, sadness, fear, anger, surprise and disgust. The subject was required to name the appropriate emotion for each slide. The latter task consisted of correctly identifying the appropriate emotion for each of 36 brief verbal narratives representing contexts connotative of the same six transcultural emotions. The CHI patients were impaired overall on the FTE but not the CTE. However, the ability to identify anger was significantly impaired on both tasks when considered in isolation from the other emotions. It was concluded that a processing deficit of primary emotional material, particularly anger, does exist following CHI, but that this deficit is not necessarily independent of task and/or modality parameters. It was also concluded that evidence of a pragmatic deficit of the language function following CHI remains to be provided at this time.
虽然已证实闭合性颅脑损伤(CHI)后会出现多种情感障碍,但语言交流功能的缺陷,尤其是句子层面和超句子层面的语用方面,虽有人提出但尚未得到证实。本研究比较了31名正常人和31名年龄、性别及受教育程度相匹配的重度闭合性颅脑损伤患者。因变量测量包括面部情绪测试(FTE)和情境情绪测试(CTE)。前一项任务由36张幻灯片组成,展示了Ekman及其同事证实具有跨文化性的六种情绪的面部表情,即高兴、悲伤、恐惧、愤怒、惊讶和厌恶。受试者需为每张幻灯片说出相应的情绪。后一项任务包括为36个简短的言语叙述正确识别相应的情绪,这些叙述代表了同样六种跨文化情绪的隐含情境。CHI患者在FTE上整体受损,但在CTE上未受损。然而,单独考虑时,CHI患者在两项任务中识别愤怒情绪的能力均显著受损。研究得出结论,CHI后确实存在对基本情绪材料的加工缺陷,尤其是对愤怒情绪的加工缺陷,但这种缺陷不一定独立于任务和/或模态参数。研究还得出结论,目前仍需提供CHI后语言功能语用缺陷的证据。