Mehdizadeh Sina
Biomechanics and Performance Analysis Department, Podium Division, National Sports Institute of Malaysia, National Sports Complex, Bukit Jalil, 57000 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Gait Posture. 2018 Feb;60:241-250. doi: 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2017.12.016. Epub 2017 Dec 16.
The largest Lyapunov exponent (LyE) is an accepted method to quantify gait stability in young and old adults. However, a range of LyE values has been reported in the literature for healthy young and elderly adults in normal walking. Therefore, it has been impractical to use the LyE as a clinical measure of gait stability. The aims of this systematic review were to summarize different methodological approaches of quantifying LyE, as well as to classify LyE values of different body segments and joints in young and elderly individuals during normal walking. The Pubmed, Ovid Medline, Scopus and ISI Web of Knowledge databases were searched using keywords related to gait, stability, variability, and LyE. Only English language articles using the Lyapunov exponent to quantify the stability of healthy normal young and old subjects walking on a level surface were considered. 102 papers were included for full-text review and data extraction. Data associated with the walking surface, data recording method, sampling rate, walking speed, body segments and joints, number of strides/steps, variable type, filtering, time-normalizing, state space dimension, time delay, LyE algorithm, and the LyE values were extracted. The disparity in implementation and calculation of the LyE was from, (i) experiment design, (ii) data pre-processing, and (iii) LyE calculation method. For practical implementation of LyE as a measure of gait stability in clinical settings, a standard and universally accepted approach of calculating LyE is required. Therefore, future studies should look for a standard and generalized procedure to apply and calculate LyE.
最大Lyapunov指数(LyE)是一种被认可的量化年轻人和老年人步态稳定性的方法。然而,文献中报道了正常行走的健康年轻人和老年人的一系列LyE值。因此,将LyE用作步态稳定性的临床指标并不实际。本系统评价的目的是总结量化LyE的不同方法学途径,并对年轻人和老年人在正常行走过程中不同身体节段和关节的LyE值进行分类。使用与步态、稳定性、变异性和LyE相关的关键词搜索了Pubmed、Ovid Medline、Scopus和ISI Web of Knowledge数据库。仅考虑使用Lyapunov指数量化健康正常年轻人和老年人在水平面上行走稳定性的英文文章。纳入102篇论文进行全文审查和数据提取。提取与行走表面、数据记录方法、采样率、行走速度、身体节段和关节、步数/步伐数、变量类型、滤波、时间归一化、状态空间维度、时间延迟、LyE算法以及LyE值相关的数据。LyE在实施和计算方面的差异源于:(i)实验设计,(ii)数据预处理,以及(iii)LyE计算方法。为了在临床环境中将LyE实际用作步态稳定性的指标,需要一种标准且被普遍接受的计算LyE的方法。因此,未来的研究应寻找一种标准且通用的程序来应用和计算LyE。