Anderson Andrew J, Asokan Rashima, Murata Hiroshi, Asaoka Ryo
Department of Optometry and Vision Sciences, The University of Melbourne, Parkville, Australia.
Elite School of Optometry, Medical Research Foundation, Chennai, India.
Ophthalmic Physiol Opt. 2018 Mar;38(2):174-182. doi: 10.1111/opo.12439. Epub 2018 Jan 8.
Previous work has investigated whether a significant regression slope in the first 2 years for the summary index Mean Deviation (MD) is predictive of rapid (≤-2 dB year ) glaucomatous visual field progression. This work assumed six visual fields were obtained as per management guidelines, but in clinical practice commonly only two or three fields are measured. We used simulation methods to investigate how reducing test frequency influences the prediction of rapid visual field progression, along with the influence of including criteria based on regression slope.
We simulated visual field series (N = 100 000) spaced annually in the first 2 years and then biennially. We calculated positive and negative predictive values (PPV & NPV) for detecting rapid progression, based on a criterion of a significant negative regression slope of any magnitude, or of a magnitude less than a particular limit. We performed a second simulation using test frequency and disease prevalence parameters from a dataset of 255 glaucoma patients from The University of Tokyo Hospital, to check the validity of our method.
Prediction values at 2 years were slightly less than those obtained using six visual fields. An addition of an appropriate slope based criterion materially improved PPV, with little detrimental effect on NPV. Simulated prediction values for the Tokyo dataset were similar to those determined empirically.
Infrequent visual field testing does not dramatically alter predictive values at 2 years, but does substantially delay when significant progression may first be detected.
以往的研究探讨了汇总指标平均偏差(MD)在前两年的显著回归斜率是否可预测青光眼性视野快速进展(≤-2 dB/年)。这项研究假设按照管理指南获得了6次视野检查结果,但在临床实践中通常仅测量2次或3次视野。我们使用模拟方法来研究减少检查频率如何影响快速视野进展的预测,以及纳入基于回归斜率的标准的影响。
我们模拟了前两年每年一次、之后每两年一次的视野系列(N = 100 000)。我们根据任何幅度的显著负回归斜率或小于特定限值的幅度标准,计算了检测快速进展的阳性和阴性预测值(PPV和NPV)。我们使用东京大学医院255例青光眼患者数据集的检查频率和疾病患病率参数进行了第二次模拟,以检验我们方法的有效性。
2年时的预测值略低于使用6次视野检查获得的预测值。添加适当的基于斜率的标准可显著提高PPV,而对NPV几乎没有不利影响。东京数据集的模拟预测值与经验确定的值相似。
不频繁的视野检查不会显著改变2年时的预测值,但会大幅延迟首次检测到显著进展的时间。