Département de mathématiques et de statistique, Université Laval, Québec, Québec, Canada.
Département des sciences du bois et de la forêt, Université Laval, Québec, Québec, Canada.
PLoS One. 2018 Jan 10;13(1):e0189860. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0189860. eCollection 2018.
Factors affecting wildland-fire size distribution include weather, fuels, and fire suppression activities. We present a novel application of survival analysis to quantify the effects of these factors on a sample of sizes of lightning-caused fires from Alberta, Canada. Two events were observed for each fire: the size at initial assessment (by the first fire fighters to arrive at the scene) and the size at "being held" (a state when no further increase in size is expected). We developed a statistical classifier to try to predict cases where there will be a growth in fire size (i.e., the size at "being held" exceeds the size at initial assessment). Logistic regression was preferred over two alternative classifiers, with covariates consistent with similar past analyses. We conducted survival analysis on the group of fires exhibiting a size increase. A screening process selected three covariates: an index of fire weather at the day the fire started, the fuel type burning at initial assessment, and a factor for the type and capabilities of the method of initial attack. The Cox proportional hazards model performed better than three accelerated failure time alternatives. Both fire weather and fuel type were highly significant, with effects consistent with known fire behaviour. The effects of initial attack method were not statistically significant, but did suggest a reverse causality that could arise if fire management agencies were to dispatch resources based on a-priori assessment of fire growth potentials. We discuss how a more sophisticated analysis of larger data sets could produce unbiased estimates of fire suppression effect under such circumstances.
影响林火规模分布的因素包括天气、燃料和火灾扑救活动。我们提出了生存分析的新应用,以量化这些因素对加拿大阿尔伯塔省闪电引发火灾样本大小的影响。每起火灾都观察到两个事件:初始评估时的大小(由第一批到达现场的消防队员评估)和“被控制”时的大小(预计不会进一步增加的状态)。我们开发了一个统计分类器,试图预测火灾规模会增长的情况(即“被控制”时的大小超过初始评估时的大小)。逻辑回归比两个替代分类器更受欢迎,协变量与类似的过去分析一致。我们对表现出规模增长的火灾组进行了生存分析。筛选过程选择了三个协变量:火灾开始当天的火灾天气指数、初始评估时燃烧的燃料类型以及初始攻击方法的类型和能力因素。Cox 比例风险模型的表现优于三个加速失效时间替代模型。火灾天气和燃料类型都非常重要,其影响与已知的火灾行为一致。初始攻击方法的影响在统计学上并不显著,但确实表明,如果消防管理机构根据火灾增长潜力的预先评估来调度资源,可能会出现反向因果关系。我们讨论了在这种情况下,对更大数据集进行更复杂的分析如何产生火灾抑制效果的无偏估计。