Unit of Epidemiology and Global Health, Department of Public Health and Clinical Medicine, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Demography and Growth Planning, Northern Institute, Charles Darwin University, Darwin, Australia.
Int J Equity Health. 2018 Jan 11;17(1):6. doi: 10.1186/s12939-018-0718-z.
The purpose of this paper is to propose a protocol for researching the impact of rural youth health service strategies on health care access. There has been no published comprehensive assessment of the effectiveness of youth health strategies in rural areas, and there is no clearly articulated model of how such assessments might be conducted. The protocol described here aims to gather information to; i) Assess rural youth access to health care according to their needs, ii) Identify and understand the strategies developed in rural areas to promote youth access to health care, and iii) Propose actions for further improvement. The protocol is described with particular reference to research being undertaken in the four northernmost counties of Sweden, which contain a widely dispersed and diverse youth population.
The protocol proposes qualitative and quantitative methodologies sequentially in four phases. First, to map youth access to health care according to their health care needs, including assessing horizontal equity (equal use of health care for equivalent health needs,) and vertical equity (people with greater health needs should receive more health care than those with lesser needs). Second, a multiple case study design investigates strategies developed across the region (youth clinics, internet applications, public health programs) to improve youth access to health care. Third, qualitative comparative analysis of the 24 rural municipalities in the region identifies the best combination of conditions leading to high youth access to health care. Fourth, a concept mapping study involving rural stakeholders, care providers and youth provides recommended actions to improve rural youth access to health care.
The implementation of this research protocol will contribute to 1) generating knowledge that could contribute to strengthening rural youth access to health care, as well as to 2) advancing the application of mixed methods to explore access to health care.
本文旨在提出一个研究农村青年健康服务策略对医疗保健可及性影响的方案。目前,尚未有针对农村地区青年健康策略有效性的综合评估,也没有明确阐述如何进行此类评估的模型。本方案旨在收集信息,以:i)根据农村青年的需求评估其获得医疗保健的情况,ii)确定和了解农村地区为促进青年获得医疗保健而制定的策略,以及 iii)提出进一步改进的措施。本方案特别参考了瑞典最北部四个县正在进行的研究,这些县的青年人口分布广泛,且多样化。
本方案提出了一种定性和定量的方法,分为四个阶段。首先,根据青年的医疗保健需求,评估其获得医疗保健的情况,包括评估水平公平性(即对于同等的医疗需求,公平使用医疗保健)和垂直公平性(即医疗需求较大的人应比需求较小的人获得更多的医疗保健)。其次,采用多案例研究设计,调查整个地区(青年诊所、互联网应用程序、公共卫生计划)制定的改善青年获得医疗保健的策略。第三,对该地区 24 个农村自治市的条件进行定性比较分析,确定导致青年获得医疗保健水平较高的最佳组合条件。第四,一项涉及农村利益相关者、医疗服务提供者和青年的概念映射研究提供了改善农村青年获得医疗保健的建议措施。
本研究方案的实施将有助于:1)产生有助于加强农村青年获得医疗保健的知识,以及 2)推进混合方法的应用,以探索医疗保健的可及性。