Department of Epidemiology and Global Health, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Arctic Research Centre (Arcum), Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Int J Equity Health. 2020 Oct 2;19(1):171. doi: 10.1186/s12939-020-01288-z.
This study emerges as a response to the lack of youth perspectives when it comes to discussions about access to and experiences of health and social services in rural areas. It subsequently contributes to the literature by positioning young people at the centre of this debate, and by taking a more holistic approach to the topic than is typically the case. Specifically, based on the idea that a good life in proper health for young people may be contingent on notions of care that are bounded up in multi-layered social and spatial environments, the aim of this study was to explore what characterises 'landscapes of care' for rural youth.
In this qualitative study, the participants included young people and professionals residing in five diverse areas across the northern Swedish 'peripheral' inland. Individual interviews (16 in total) and focus group discussions (26 in total) were conducted with 63 youth aged 14-27 years and with 44 professionals operating across sectors such as health centres, school health, integration units, youth clinics and youth clubs. Following an emergent design and using thematic analysis, we developed one main theme, 'landscapes of care and despair', comprising the two themes: '(dis)connectedness' and 'extended support or troubling gaps'.
The findings illustrate how various health-promoting and potentially harmful aspects acting at structural, organisational and interpersonal levels contributed to dynamic landscapes characterised simultaneously by care and despair. In particular, our study shows how rural youths' feelings of belongingness to people and places coupled with opportunities to participate in society and access practical and emotional support appear to facilitate their care within rural settings. However, although the results indicate that some in the diverse group of rural youth were cared for and about, a negative picture was painted in parallel. These aspects of despair included youths' senses of exclusion and marginalisation, degrading attitudes towards them and their problems, as well as recurrent gaps in the provision and practices of care.
To gain a more comprehensive understanding about the health of rural youth, this study highlights the benefits investigating 'care-ful' and 'uncaring' aspects bounded up in dynamic and multi-layered landscapes.
本研究旨在回应在讨论农村地区的卫生和社会服务获取途径和经验时缺乏青年视角的问题。它通过将年轻人置于这场辩论的中心,并采取比通常更全面的方法来探讨这个话题,从而为文献做出了贡献。具体来说,基于年轻人健康生活的良好状态可能取决于与多层次社会和空间环境交织在一起的关怀观念这一理念,本研究旨在探讨农村青年的“关怀景观”的特点。
在这项定性研究中,参与者包括居住在瑞典北部“边缘”内陆地区五个不同地区的年轻人和专业人士。对 63 名年龄在 14-27 岁之间的年轻人和 44 名从事卫生中心、学校卫生、融合单位、青年诊所和青年俱乐部等部门工作的专业人士进行了个人访谈(共 16 次)和焦点小组讨论(共 26 次)。采用新兴设计并使用主题分析,我们提出了一个主要主题,即“关怀与绝望的景观”,其中包括两个主题:“(脱)联系”和“扩展支持或令人不安的差距”。
研究结果表明,在结构、组织和人际关系层面上,各种促进健康和潜在有害的方面如何共同促成了充满关怀和绝望的动态景观。特别是,我们的研究表明,农村青年对人与地方的归属感以及参与社会和获得实际和情感支持的机会,似乎有助于他们在农村环境中得到关怀。然而,尽管研究结果表明,多样化的农村青年群体中的一些人得到了关怀和关注,但同时也描绘了一幅负面的画面。这些绝望的方面包括年轻人的排斥感和边缘化感、对他们及其问题的贬低态度,以及关怀提供和实践中的反复出现的差距。
为了更全面地了解农村青年的健康状况,本研究强调了调查“关怀”和“不关怀”方面的好处,这些方面受到动态和多层次景观的影响。