Fussell Elizabeth, Curran Sara R, Dunbar Matthew D, Babb Michael A, Thompson Luanne, Meijer-Irons Jacqueline
Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci. 2017 Jan;669(1):146-167. doi: 10.1177/0002716216682942. Epub 2016 Dec 20.
Environmental determinists predict that people move away from places experiencing frequent weather hazards, yet some of these areas have rapidly growing populations. This analysis examines the relationship between weather events and population change in all U.S. counties that experienced hurricanes and tropical storms between 1980 and 2012. Our database allows for more generalizable conclusions by accounting for heterogeneity in current and past hurricane events and losses and past population trends. We find that hurricanes and tropical storms affect future population growth only in counties with growing, high-density populations, which are only 2 percent of all counties. In those counties, current year hurricane events and related losses suppress future population growth, although cumulative hurricane-related losses actually elevate population growth. Low-density counties and counties with stable or declining populations experience no effect of these weather events. Our analysis provides a methodologically informed explanation for contradictory findings in prior studies.
环境决定论者预测,人们会搬离经常遭受天气灾害的地区,但其中一些地区的人口却在迅速增长。本分析考察了1980年至2012年间经历过飓风和热带风暴的美国所有县的天气事件与人口变化之间的关系。我们的数据库通过考虑当前和过去飓风事件及损失的异质性以及过去的人口趋势,得出了更具普遍性的结论。我们发现,飓风和热带风暴仅对人口增长且密度高的县的未来人口增长产生影响,而这类县仅占所有县的2%。在那些县,当年的飓风事件及相关损失会抑制未来人口增长,尽管与飓风相关的累计损失实际上会提高人口增长。低密度县以及人口稳定或减少的县并未受到这些天气事件的影响。我们的分析为先前研究中的矛盾发现提供了一个有方法依据的解释。