Kim Hyo-Jung, Kim Ji-Soo
Research Administration Team, Seoul National University Bundang Hospital, Seongnam, South Korea.
Department of Neurology, College of Medicine, Seoul National University, Seoul National University Bundang Hospital, Seongnam, South Korea.
Front Neurol. 2017 Dec 15;8:690. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2017.00690. eCollection 2017.
Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) recurs frequently. This study aims to determine that each patient with BPPV has a predilection for a specific canal and the type of recurred BPPV can be predicted from that observed during the previous attack.
The involved side (right, left, and bilateral) and affected canal (posterior, geotropic horizontal, apogeotropic horizontal, anterior, and mixed) were analyzed in 224 pairs of consecutive attacks of BPPV confirmed in 167 patients at the Dizziness Clinic of Seoul National Bundang Hospital from 2003 to 2017. We defined the recurrence when patients had the redevelopment of BPPV at least 1 week after resolution of the previous one.
During the initial attack, the involved canals were posterior in 134 (59.8%), geotropic horizontal in 53 (23.7%), apogeotropic horizontal in 27 (12.1%), anterior in 5 (2.2%), and mixed in 5 (2.2%). The right ear was more commonly affected than the left ear [132 (58.9%) vs. 90 (40.2%)]. Two patients (0.9%) showed bilateral involvements. During the recurrences, the proportions of involved canals and affected side were similar irrespective of those during the former event. Only 24% of the patients showed the recurrence in the same canal on the same side.
The patterns of recurrences are usually discordant in patients with BPPV. Instruction for self-administration of a specific canalith repositioning procedure based on the previous type of BPPV may have a limited efficacy in this frequently recurrent disorder.
良性阵发性位置性眩晕(BPPV)经常复发。本研究旨在确定每位BPPV患者对特定半规管有偏好,且可根据前次发作时观察到的情况预测复发性BPPV的类型。
分析了2003年至2017年在首尔国立盆唐医院眩晕门诊确诊的167例患者的224对连续BPPV发作,记录受累侧(右侧、左侧和双侧)和受累半规管(后半规管、地向性水平半规管、背地性水平半规管、前半规管和混合型)。我们将患者在前一次BPPV发作缓解至少1周后再次出现BPPV定义为复发。
初次发作时,受累半规管为后半规管的有134例(59.8%),地向性水平半规管的有53例(23.7%),背地性水平半规管的有27例(12.1%),前半规管的有5例(2.2%),混合型的有5例(2.2%)。右侧耳朵比左侧耳朵更常受累[132例(58.9%)对90例(40.2%)]。2例患者(0.9%)表现为双侧受累。复发时,无论前次发作情况如何,受累半规管和受累侧的比例相似。只有24%的患者在同一侧的同一半规管复发。
BPPV患者的复发模式通常不一致。基于前次BPPV类型进行特定半规管复位手法的自我管理指导,在这种频繁复发的疾病中可能效果有限。