Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron road, Berkeley, California 94720, USA.
Lasers Interactions and Dynamics Laboratory, CEA Saclay, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France.
Phys Rev E. 2017 Sep;96(3-1):033305. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevE.96.033305. Epub 2017 Sep 11.
With the advent of petawatt class lasers, the very large laser intensities attainable on target should enable the production of intense high-order Doppler harmonics from relativistic laser-plasma mirror interactions. At present, the modeling of these harmonics with particle-in-cell (PIC) codes is extremely challenging as it implies an accurate description of tens to hundreds of harmonic orders on a broad range of angles. In particular, we show here that due to the numerical dispersion of waves they induce in vacuum, standard finite difference time domain (FDTD) Maxwell solvers employed in most PIC codes can induce a spurious angular deviation of harmonic beams potentially degrading simulation results. This effect was extensively studied and a simple toy model based on the Snell-Descartes law was developed that allows us to finely predict the angular deviation of harmonics depending on the spatiotemporal resolution and the Maxwell solver used in the simulations. Our model demonstrates that the mitigation of this numerical artifact with FDTD solvers mandates very high spatiotemporal resolution preventing realistic three-dimensional (3D) simulations even on the largest computers available at the time of writing. We finally show that nondispersive pseudospectral analytical time domain solvers can considerably reduce the spatiotemporal resolution required to mitigate this spurious deviation and should enable in the near future 3D accurate modeling on supercomputers in a realistic time to solution.
随着皮秒级激光的出现,在目标上实现的非常大的激光强度应该能够从相对论激光等离子体反射相互作用中产生强烈的高阶多普勒谐波。目前,用粒子模拟(PIC)代码对这些谐波进行建模极具挑战性,因为它需要在广泛的角度范围内对数十到数百个谐波阶进行精确描述。特别是,我们在这里展示,由于它们在真空中诱导的波的数值色散,大多数 PIC 代码中使用的标准有限差分时域(FDTD)麦克斯韦求解器可能会导致谐波光束的虚假角度偏差,从而可能降低模拟结果。我们对这种影响进行了广泛的研究,并开发了一个简单的基于斯涅尔-笛卡尔定律的玩具模型,该模型使我们能够根据模拟中使用的时空分辨率和麦克斯韦求解器,精细地预测谐波的角度偏差。我们的模型表明,用 FDTD 求解器来缓解这种数值伪影需要非常高的时空分辨率,即使在编写本文时可用的最大计算机上,也会阻止现实的三维(3D)模拟。最后,我们表明,非色散赝谱解析时域求解器可以大大减少缓解这种虚假偏差所需的时空分辨率,并应在不久的将来能够在超级计算机上以现实的求解时间实现 3D 精确建模。