van der Ster Björn J P, Bennis Frank C, Delhaas Tammo, Westerhof Berend E, Stok Wim J, van Lieshout Johannes J
Department of Internal Medicine, Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Department of Medical Biology, Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Front Physiol. 2018 Jan 5;8:1057. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2017.01057. eCollection 2017.
In the initial phase of hypovolemic shock, mean blood pressure (BP) is maintained by sympathetically mediated vasoconstriction rendering BP monitoring insensitive to detect blood loss early. Late detection can result in reduced tissue oxygenation and eventually cellular death. We hypothesized that a machine learning algorithm that interprets currently used and new hemodynamic parameters could facilitate in the detection of impending hypovolemic shock. In 42 (27 female) young [mean (sd): 24 (4) years], healthy subjects central blood volume (CBV) was progressively reduced by application of -50 mmHg lower body negative pressure until the onset of pre-syncope. A support vector machine was trained to classify samples into normovolemia (class 0), initial phase of CBV reduction (class 1) or advanced CBV reduction (class 2). Nine models making use of different features were computed to compare sensitivity and specificity of different non-invasive hemodynamic derived signals. : volumetric hemodynamic parameters (stroke volume and cardiac output), BP curve dynamics, near-infrared spectroscopy determined cortical brain oxygenation, end-tidal carbon dioxide pressure, thoracic bio-impedance, and middle cerebral artery transcranial Doppler (TCD) blood flow velocity. : sensitivity and specificity, absolute error, and quantification of the log odds ratio of class 2 vs. class 0 probability estimates. The combination with maximal sensitivity and specificity for classes 1 and 2 was found for the model comprising volumetric features (class 1: 0.73-0.98 and class 2: 0.56-0.96). Overall lowest model error was found for the models comprising TCD curve hemodynamics. Using probability estimates the best combination of sensitivity for class 1 (0.67) and specificity (0.87) was found for the model that contained the TCD cerebral blood flow velocity derived pulse height. The highest combination for class 2 was found for the model with the volumetric features (0.72 and 0.91). The most sensitive models for the detection of advanced CBV reduction comprised data that describe features from volumetric parameters and from cerebral blood flow velocity hemodynamics. In a validated model of hemorrhage in humans these parameters provide the best indication of the progression of central hypovolemia.
在低血容量性休克的初始阶段,平均血压(BP)通过交感神经介导的血管收缩得以维持,这使得血压监测对于早期失血的检测不敏感。延迟检测会导致组织氧合减少,最终导致细胞死亡。我们假设一种能够解读当前使用的和新的血流动力学参数的机器学习算法有助于检测即将发生的低血容量性休克。在42名(27名女性)年轻[平均(标准差):24(4)岁]健康受试者中,通过施加-50 mmHg的下体负压逐渐减少中心血容量(CBV),直至前驱晕厥发作。训练了一个支持向量机,将样本分类为血容量正常(0类)、CBV减少的初始阶段(1类)或CBV严重减少(2类)。计算了九个利用不同特征的模型,以比较不同无创血流动力学衍生信号的敏感性和特异性:容积血流动力学参数(每搏输出量和心输出量)、血压曲线动态、近红外光谱法测定的大脑皮层氧合、呼气末二氧化碳分压、胸段生物阻抗以及大脑中动脉经颅多普勒(TCD)血流速度。:敏感性和特异性、绝对误差以及2类与0类概率估计的对数优势比的量化。发现包含容积特征的模型(1类:0.73 - 0.98,2类:0.56 - 0.96)对于1类和2类具有最大的敏感性和特异性组合。发现包含TCD曲线血流动力学的模型总体误差最低。使用概率估计,发现包含TCD脑血流速度衍生的脉冲高度的模型对于1类的敏感性(0.67)和特异性(0.87)的最佳组合。发现具有容积特征的模型对于2类的最高组合(0.72和0.91)。检测CBV严重减少的最敏感模型包含描述容积参数和脑血流速度血流动力学特征的数据。在经过验证的人体出血模型中,这些参数能最好地指示中心低血容量的进展情况。