Aldhwaihi Khaled, Schifano Fabrizio, Pezzolesi Cinzia, Umaru Nkiruka
Department of Pharmacy, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield, UK.
Integr Pharm Res Pract. 2016 Jan 12;5:1-10. doi: 10.2147/IPRP.S95733. eCollection 2016.
Dispensing errors are common in hospital pharmacies. Investigating dispensing errors is important for identifying the factors involved and developing strategies to reduce their occurrence.
To review published studies exploring the incidence and types of dispensing errors in hospital pharmacies and factors contributing to these errors.
Electronic databases including PubMed, Scopus, Ovid, and Web of Science were searched for articles published between January 2000 and January 2015. Inclusion criteria were: studies published in English, and studies investigating type, incidence and factors contributing to dispensing errors in hospital pharmacies. One researcher searched for all relevant published articles, screened all titles and abstracts, and obtained complete articles. A second researcher assessed the titles, abstracts, and complete articles to verify the reliability of the selected articles.
Fifteen studies met the inclusion criteria all of which were conducted in just four countries. Reviewing incident reports and direct observation were the main methods used to investigate dispensing errors. Dispensing error rates varied between countries (0.015%-33.5%) depending on the dispensing system, research method, and classification of dispensing error types. The most frequent dispensing errors reported were dispensing the wrong medicine, dispensing the wrong drug strength, and dispensing the wrong dosage form. The most common factors associated with dispensing errors were: high workload, low staffing, mix-up of look-alike/ sound-alike drugs, lack of knowledge/experience, distractions/interruptions, and communication problems within the dispensary team.
Studies relating to dispensing errors in hospital pharmacies are few in number and have been conducted in just four countries. The majority of these studies focused on the investigation of dispensing error types with no mention of contributing factors or strategies for reducing dispensing errors. Others studies are thus needed to investigate dispensing errors in hospital pharmacies, and a combined approach is recommended to investigate contributing factors associated with dispensing errors and explore strategies for reducing these errors.
调配差错在医院药房很常见。调查调配差错对于识别其中涉及的因素以及制定减少其发生的策略很重要。
回顾已发表的研究,探讨医院药房调配差错的发生率、类型以及导致这些差错的因素。
检索包括PubMed、Scopus、Ovid和Web of Science在内的电子数据库,查找2000年1月至2015年1月发表的文章。纳入标准为:英文发表的研究,以及调查医院药房调配差错类型、发生率和促成因素的研究。一名研究人员搜索所有相关发表文章,筛选所有标题和摘要,并获取完整文章。另一名研究人员评估标题、摘要和完整文章,以核实所选文章的可靠性。
15项研究符合纳入标准,所有这些研究仅在四个国家进行。审查事件报告和直接观察是调查调配差错的主要方法。根据调配系统、研究方法和调配差错类型的分类,各国的调配差错率有所不同(0.015%-33.5%)。报告的最常见调配差错是配发错误的药品、错误的药物强度和错误的剂型。与调配差错相关的最常见因素是:工作量大、人员配备不足、相似/同音药物混淆、知识/经验缺乏、分心/干扰以及药房团队内部的沟通问题。
关于医院药房调配差错的研究数量很少,且仅在四个国家进行。这些研究大多侧重于调配差错类型的调查,未提及促成因素或减少调配差错的策略。因此,需要其他研究来调查医院药房的调配差错,建议采用综合方法来调查与调配差错相关的促成因素,并探索减少这些差错的策略。