Sharma Atul, Prinja Shankar, Aggarwal Arun Kumar
School of Public Health, Post-graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India.
J Public Health Res. 2018 Jan 2;6(3):917. doi: 10.4081/jphr.2017.917. eCollection 2017 Dec 13.
Limited efforts have been observed in low and middle income countries to undertake health system performance assessment at district level. Absence of a comprehensive data collection tool and lack of a standardised single summary measure defining overall performance are some of the main problems. Present study has been undertaken to develop a summary composite health system performance index at district level.
A broad range of indicators covering all six domains as per building block framework were finalized by an expert panel. The domains were classified into twenty sub-domains, with 70 input and process indicators to measure performance. Seven sub-domains for assessing health system outputs and outcomes were identified, with a total of 28 indicators. Districts in Haryana state from north India were selected for the study. Primary and secondary data will be collected from 378 health facilities, district and state health directorate headquarters. Indicators will be normalized, aggregated to generate composite performance index at district level. Domain specific scores will present the quality of individual building block domains in the public health system. Robustness of the results will be checked using sensitivity analysis.
The study presents a methodology for comprehensive assessment of all health system domains on basis of input, process, output and outcome indicators which has never been reported from India. Generation of this index will help identify policy and implementation areas of concern and point towards potential solutions. Results may also help understand relationships between individual building blocks and their sub-components.
在低收入和中等收入国家,在地区层面开展卫生系统绩效评估的工作力度有限。缺乏综合数据收集工具以及缺乏定义整体绩效的标准化单一汇总指标是一些主要问题。本研究旨在制定地区层面的综合卫生系统绩效汇总指数。
一个专家小组最终确定了涵盖根据构建模块框架划分的所有六个领域的广泛指标。这些领域被分为20个子领域,有70个投入和过程指标来衡量绩效。确定了7个用于评估卫生系统产出和结果的子领域,共有28个指标。选取了印度北部哈里亚纳邦的地区进行研究。将从378个卫生设施、地区和邦卫生部门总部收集初级和二级数据。指标将进行标准化处理并汇总,以生成地区层面的综合绩效指数。特定领域得分将呈现公共卫生系统中各个构建模块领域的质量。将使用敏感性分析来检验结果的稳健性。
该研究提出了一种基于投入、过程、产出和结果指标对所有卫生系统领域进行综合评估的方法,这在印度从未有过报道。生成这个指数将有助于确定需要关注的政策和实施领域,并指出潜在的解决方案。结果还可能有助于理解各个构建模块及其子组件之间的关系。