Curtis G, McGregor Argo C, Jones D, Grove-White D
Department of Obesity and Endocrinology, Institute of Ageing and Chronic Disease, University of Liverpool, Leahurst Campus, Neston, Wirral, United Kingdom.
School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Surrey, Guilford, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2018 Feb 14;13(2):e0191687. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0191687. eCollection 2018.
Contentious issues in calf rearing include milk feeding practices and single versus group housing. The current study was performed on a high producing 170 Holstein cow dairy farm, to investigate the impact of nutrition and housing on growth and reproduction. Heifer calves (n = 100) were allocated in birth order to one of two commonly used management strategies. All calves received 3-4 litres of dam specific colostrum within 6 hours of birth. Group A calves were group housed from birth and fed milk replacer (MR) ad libitum via a computerised machine utilising a single teat, with weaning commencing at 63 days of age. Group R calves were initially housed in individual pens and received 2.5 litres of MR twice daily via a bucket until 21 days of age when they were group housed and fed 3 litres of MR twice daily via a group trough with weaning commencing at 56 days. From 12 weeks of age onwards, calves in both dietary groups were subject to common nutritional and husbandry protocols. All breeding of heifers was via artificial insemination with no hormonal intervention. Calves were weighed, body condition scored and morphometric measures recorded weekly up till 12 weeks of age then monthly until conception. Pre-weaning growth rates (kg/day) were significantly higher in Group A calves compared to Group R (0.89, 95% CI 0.86-0.93 vs 0.57, 95% CI 0.54-0.6 kg/day P < 0.001) with the most marked differences observed during the first three weeks of life (0.72, 95% CI 0.61-0.82 vs 0.17, 95% CI 0.08-0.26 P < 0.001). Whilst Group A calves gained body condition score (BCS) throughout the pre-weaning phase, Group R calves lost BCS during the first 4 weeks of life. Data suggested that Group R calves supported skeletal growth during this period by catabolising body tissue. Group A calves had a greater risk of disease than group R calves during the pre-weaning phase (diarrhoea: odds ratio 3.86, 95% CI 1.67-8.9; pneumonia: odds ratio 5.80, 95% CI 2.33-14.44) although no calves died during this period. Whilst pneumonia had a significant impact on growth during the study duration (P = 0.008), this was not the case for diarrhoea. Whilst univariate analysis failed to show any statistically significant group differences (P > 0.050) in any of the mean values of measured reproductive parameters, multivariable Cox regression suggested that there was a weak trend (P = 0.072) for Group A animals to achieve first service earlier than their Group R counterparts (62.6 weeks versus 65.3 weeks). Irrespective of dietary group, the hazard for achievement of all measured reproductive parameters, apart from time to puberty, was 20-40% less for heifers borne from multiparous dams compared to heifers from primiparous dams.
犊牛饲养中的争议性问题包括喂奶方式以及单栏饲养与群养。本研究在一个拥有170头高产荷斯坦奶牛的奶牛场进行,旨在调查营养和饲养方式对生长及繁殖的影响。将100头小母牛犊按出生顺序分配到两种常用的管理策略之一。所有犊牛在出生后6小时内都摄入了3 - 4升来自其生母的初乳。A组犊牛从出生就进行群养,并通过一台使用单个奶嘴的电脑控制机器随意采食代乳粉(MR),63日龄开始断奶。R组犊牛最初单独饲养在栏舍中,每天通过桶分两次喂食2.5升代乳粉,直到21日龄,之后改为群养,并通过群槽每天分两次喂食3升代乳粉,56日龄开始断奶。从12周龄起,两个饮食组的犊牛都遵循相同的营养和饲养规程。所有小母牛的配种均通过人工授精,无激素干预。每周对犊牛进行称重、体况评分并记录形态学指标,直至12周龄,之后每月记录一次直至受孕。断奶前A组犊牛的生长速度(千克/天)显著高于R组(0.89,95%置信区间0.86 - 0.93对比0.57,95%置信区间0.54 - 0.6千克/天,P < 0.001),在出生后的前三周差异最为明显(0.72,95%置信区间0.61 - 0.82对比0.17,95%置信区间0.08 - 0.26,P < 0.001)。在断奶前阶段,A组犊牛的体况评分(BCS)增加,而R组犊牛在出生后的前4周体况评分下降。数据表明,在此期间R组犊牛通过分解身体组织来支持骨骼生长。断奶前阶段A组犊牛患病风险高于R组犊牛(腹泻:优势比3.86,95%置信区间1.67 - 8.9;肺炎:优势比5.80,95%置信区间2.33 - 14.44),不过在此期间没有犊牛死亡。虽然肺炎在研究期间对生长有显著影响(P = 0.008),但腹泻并非如此。单因素分析未能显示在任何测量的繁殖参数均值上存在任何统计学显著的组间差异(P > 0.050),多变量Cox回归表明A组动物比R组动物更早达到首次配种存在微弱趋势(P = 0.072)(分别为62.6周和65.3周)。无论饮食组如何,与初产母牛所生的小母牛相比,经产母牛所生的小母牛达到所有测量繁殖参数(除青春期时间外)的风险低20 - 40%。