Department of Environmental Health Sciences, Graduate School of Public Health, Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea.
Institute of Health and Environment, Seoul National University, Seoul, South Korea.
Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2018 Apr;94:240-244. doi: 10.1016/j.yrtph.2018.02.007. Epub 2018 Feb 12.
Deterministic exposure assessment has uncertainty about the selection of input parameters on the resulting estimates. The purpose of this study was to compare inhalation exposures estimated by a specific percentile of each of the three exposure factors in deterministic assessment with population exposure. Exposure to nine household care products, namely a deodorizer, six cleaning products, and two disinfectants were investigated. The population exposures were individually calculated for three exposure factors (frequency of use, amount of use, and duration of use) from an existing database of 3333 participants representing the national population. Deterministic exposure assessment was conducted according to various percentiles of exposure factors. 99th percentiles of population exposure in all nine consumer products were 1.3-2.4 times greater than the 95th percentiles. Inhalation exposures based on the 75th percentiles of each of the three exposure factors in deterministic assessment were much lower than the 95th percentiles of the population exposure. Deterministic exposure estimates using 85th to 99th percentiles of each of the three exposure factors were closer to the 95th percentiles of the population exposure. We concluded that exposure factors in deterministic assessment should be greater than the 75th percentile to more precisely estimate exposure of at-risk groups.
确定性暴露评估在选择输入参数时存在不确定性,这会影响到评估结果的准确性。本研究旨在比较三种暴露因素中每个因素的特定百分位数所估计的吸入暴露与人群暴露之间的差异。研究对象为九种家用护理产品,包括空气清新剂、六种清洁产品和两种消毒剂。使用来自代表全国人口的 3333 名参与者的现有数据库,针对三种暴露因素(使用频率、使用量和使用时间)分别计算人群暴露。根据暴露因素的不同百分位数进行确定性暴露评估。在所有九种消费产品中,99 百分位数的人群暴露量是 95 百分位数的 1.3-2.4 倍。基于三种暴露因素中每个因素的 75 百分位数进行的吸入暴露量明显低于人群暴露量的 95 百分位数。使用三种暴露因素的 85 百分位至 99 百分位进行确定性暴露估计,更接近人群暴露量的 95 百分位。本研究得出结论,在进行确定性暴露评估时,暴露因素应大于 75 百分位,以更准确地估计高风险人群的暴露情况。