Quinn Sterling, Swain Nathaniel
Department of Audiology and Speech Pathology, The University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria, 3010, Australia.
Melbourne Graduate School of Education, The University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria, 3010, Australia.
J Commun Disord. 2018 Mar-Apr;72:1-15. doi: 10.1016/j.jcomdis.2018.02.001. Epub 2018 Feb 8.
Research suggests that transgender young offenders are a uniquely vulnerable caseload that may benefit from speech pathology intervention to help bring their voice into alignment with their gender identity. However, no previous studies have investigated treatment efficacy in this population. This study investigated the impact of intensive voice feminisation therapy targeting fundamental frequency and oral resonance in a 17 year old transgender individual within a youth justice institution. Acoustic analysis, listener and self-ratings of vocal femininity, self-ratings of vocal satisfaction, a post-treatment structured interview, and pre- and post- treatment completion of the Transsexual Voice Questionnaire (TVQ) were utilised to determine treatment impact. Outcome measures indicated therapy was effective at increasing the client's vocal pitch and perceptually femininity without compromising vocal quality. However, the client was still not consistently perceived as female post-intervention and had difficulty implementing feminine speech strategies in discourse. This case study provides preliminary evidence for the effectiveness of intensive voice feminisation therapy in a youth offending population. This research also highlights the potential utility of speech pathologists working in youth justice settings, even when the timeframe for intervention is limited. Furthermore, this research paper validates the use of perceptual outcome measures in transgender voice work, by replicating previous findings in which significant correlations were found between perceptual ratings of vocal gender and client satisfaction.
研究表明,跨性别青少年罪犯是一个特别脆弱的案件群体,言语病理学干预可能有助于使他们的声音与性别认同相一致。然而,此前尚无研究调查过该群体的治疗效果。本研究调查了针对一名17岁处于青少年司法机构中的跨性别个体的基频和口腔共鸣进行强化嗓音女性化治疗的影响。利用声学分析、听众及自我对嗓音女性化的评分、嗓音满意度的自我评分、治疗后的结构化访谈,以及治疗前后完成的变性者嗓音问卷(TVQ)来确定治疗效果。结果指标表明,治疗有效地提高了来访者的嗓音音高和感知到的女性特质,且未损害嗓音质量。然而,干预后该来访者仍未始终被视为女性,并且在话语中难以运用女性化的言语策略。本案例研究为强化嗓音女性化治疗在青少年犯罪群体中的有效性提供了初步证据。这项研究还凸显了言语病理学家在青少年司法环境中工作的潜在效用,即便干预时间有限。此外,本研究论文通过重复先前的研究结果,验证了在跨性别嗓音治疗中使用感知结果指标的有效性,先前研究发现在嗓音性别的感知评分与来访者满意度之间存在显著相关性。